USA TODAY International Edition

Opposing view: Founders wanted a powerful president

- GianCarlo Canaparo GianCarlo Canaparo is a legal fellow at the Heritage Foundation.

The frenzied reaction by some to Attorney General William Barr’s speech on the constituti­onal scope of executive authority was baffling.

In it, Barr addressed the unitary executive doctrine, which maintains that the executive power is vested solely in the president and can be exercised only under his supervisio­n.

This isn’t a novel ideal. The first line of Article II of the Constituti­on states: “The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America.”

And Thomas Jefferson said: “For the prompt, clear, and consistent action so necessary in an Executive, unity of person is necessary.”

Yet, Barr explained: “Over the past several decades we have seen the steady encroachme­nt on executive authority by the other branches of government” which “has substantia­lly weakened the function of the presidency to the detriment of the nation.”

In his view, the president’s “ability to act in areas in which he has discretion has become smothered by the encroachme­nts of the other branches.”

He’s right. The trend has accelerate­d with the frenetic opposition to President Donald Trump. Many on the left, including — perhaps especially — those in Congress, have made it their mission to hinder and undermine his government.

Consider Congress’s unpreceden­ted obstructio­n of executive branch nominees. Or the “deep state” employees in the executive branch who delay or undermine the president’s agenda. In short, the executive is deluged by what Barr called “a war to cripple, by any means necessary, a duly elected government.”

The unitary executive is one of the most brilliant innovation­s in the Constituti­on. As Barr explained, it “has brought to our republic a dynamism and effectiveness that other democracie­s have lacked.”

This is true whether the president is a Republican or Democrat. Those who oppose Trump should recognize that, and think twice before they tear down our constituti­onal structure just to topple the man temporaril­y on top of it.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States