USA TODAY International Edition

‘ Clarice’ joins ranks of Lecter lore

- Patrick Ryan

Hello, “Clarice.”

CBS this month premiered its moody procedural spin on FBI agent Clarice Starling, starring Rebecca Breeds in the role made famous by Jodie Foster in 1991’ s Oscar- winning “The Silence of the Lambs.” The series ( Thursdays, 10 EST/ PST) is the latest in a slew of film and TV adaptation­s of Thomas Harris’ novels about infamous cannibal Hannibal Lecter. The cultured yet calculatin­g ex- psychiatri­st first appeared in Harris’ 1981 book “Red Dragon,” and was memorably played by Anthony Hopkins in three movies ( including “Lambs,” released 30 years ago this month).

Here’s how “Clarice” ranks with the best ( and worst) Lecter fare:

7. ‘ Hannibal Rising’ ( 2007)

Why can’t we just let baddies be bad? Harris rush- released a novel and film about young Lecter ( Aaran Thomas), tracing his dire upbringing in 1940s Lithuania, where his parents were murdered and his sister was cannibaliz­ed. Now grown, Lecter ( Gaspard Ulliel) develops his own taste for flesh in a gruesome revenge- killing spree. It’s a hackneyed tale that robs the character of his chilling mystique.

6. ‘ Clarice’ ( 2021)

A show that is somehow more lifeless than Dr. Lecter’s victims. Set a year after the events of “Silence of the Lambs,” the CBS drama follows Starling ( Breeds) as she’s called back into the field to investigat­e serial killings. The series aims for nuanced exploratio­n of Starling’s childhood trauma and PTSD from the Buffalo Bill case but is hindered by flat dialogue and heavy- handed storytelli­ng. Most lethal of all, “Clarice” is unable to name or depict Lecter for legal reasons, leaving an obvious void that the show is forced to awkwardly tiptoe around.

5. ‘ Hannibal’ ( 2001)

Strangely convoluted and unpleasant­ly gory, this high- budget sequel is set 10 years after “Lambs,” as a now- disgraced Starling ( Julianne Moore) races to capture Lecter ( Hopkins) before Mason Verger ( Gary Oldman), his mutilated surviving victim, gets vengeance. Set in the U. S. and Italy, Ridley Scott’s film often feels like a grislier version of Dan Brown’s “Angels & Demons,” with a truly stomach- churning image of Ray Liotta’s exposed brain that will haunt us for a lifetime. But it’s a delight watching Hopkins turn up the camp as a bloodthirs­ty Lecter. And Moore tries her best to emulate Foster’s West Virginia accent.

4. ‘ Red Dragon’ ( 2002)

Despite being a prequel to “Lambs,” this is the last of Hopkins’ Lecter movies, as his cannibalis­tic psychiatri­st helps retired FBI agent Will Graham ( Edward Norton) catch Francis Dolarhyde ( Ralph Fiennes), also known as the Tooth Fairy killer. With a superb cast including Mary- Louise Parker and Philip Seymour Hoffman, this stylish but familiar thriller is a step up from “Hannibal.” But Norton’s Graham lacks the tortured cool of William Petersen, who originated the character in 1986’ s “Manhunter.” His interrogat­ion scenes lack the spark of Foster’s Starling, who managed to go toe- to- toe with Hopkins’ Lecter even with glass separating them.

3. ‘ Manhunter’ ( 1986)

With flickers of “Miami Vice,” Michael Mann’s neon- washed adaptation of “Red Dragon” was a critical and commercial disappoint­ment upon release, but has since been reappraise­d as one of the better Lecter movies. Set to a pulsing soundtrack, the movie tracks Graham’s ( Petersen) hunt for Francis Dolarhyde ( Tom Noonan), an avid fan of Lecter ( Brian Cox). Due to his towering physique and withdrawn demeanor, Noonan is in some ways scarier than Fiennes’ more feral take on Dolarhyde. And in a brief role, the legendary Cox (“Succession”) brings sinister charm to the first onscreen Lecter.

2. ‘ Hannibal’ ( 2013- 15)

One of the most visually stunning TV shows of the past decade, Bryan Fuller’s macabre NBC entry in the Lecter- verse was a squeamish feast for the eyes. And we couldn’t get enough of the delicious cat- and- mouse game between criminal profiler Graham ( Hugh Dancy) and Lecter ( Mads Mikkelsen); their homoerotic thrills have been matched only by “Killing Eve” in the years since.

1. ‘ The Silence of the Lambs’ ( 1991)

As if there was any other choice. Thirty years later, Jonathan Demme’s unlikely best picture Oscar winner still is an eerily spellbindi­ng masterpiec­e: meticulous­ly edited and strikingly shot, with an exhilarati­ng final 40 minutes that’s unrivaled in its intensity. Foster’s Starling remains an all- time great protagonis­t, who approaches depraved killers and leering superiors with the same level of cool- headed resolve and intuition. Hopkins, as her intellectu­al sparring partner Lecter, looms over the film with a creeping menace, gradually exposing Starling’s vulnerabil­ities and forcing her to confront her father’s death.

A twisted love story and unnerving slow burn, “Lambs” is about the masks we wear to protect and hide our true selves: as a fresh- faced FBI trainee trying to succeed in a male- dominated field, or a cannibal literally wearing his victim’s face to escape custody. That’s well worth raising a nice chianti to.

 ?? ORION PICTURES ?? Anthony Hopkins, left, and Jodie Foster won best actor and actress Oscars for their performanc­es in 1991' s “The Silence of the Lambs.”
ORION PICTURES Anthony Hopkins, left, and Jodie Foster won best actor and actress Oscars for their performanc­es in 1991' s “The Silence of the Lambs.”
 ?? ENTERTAINM­ENT DE LAURENTIIS ?? Brian Cox as Hannibal Lecter in the 1986 film “Manhunter.”
ENTERTAINM­ENT DE LAURENTIIS Brian Cox as Hannibal Lecter in the 1986 film “Manhunter.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States