USA TODAY International Edition
A race against time in Fla. waste disaster
Millions of gallons of water pumped out of reservoir to stem breaches
SARASOTA, Fla. – A drone equipped with thermal imaging equipment identified a possible “second breach” in the containment pond wall that is leaking polluted water at a fertilizer processing plant property in Florida, officials said Monday.
The drone imaging may be a sign of further structural problems within the old Piney Point fertilizer processing plant in Manatee County or, it could be nothing. A Manatee County official said it’s not clear if the drone had identified something that already was known.
The Florida Department of Environmental Protection later said that news reports – which were based on comments by two Manatee County officials – of a possible second breach were “unsubstantiated.”
“There have been news reports of a second area of seepage from the east wall of the NGS- South compartment at Piney Point. These reports are unsubstantiated,” the DEP news release states. “A technical working group ... was on- site today evaluating conditions and determined the site was safe to continue work.”
The release adds officials are continuing to monitor the one area “where there is concentrated seepage.”
The potential discovery comes as hundreds were ordered to evacuate as workers pumped millions of gallons of wastewater from the Piney Point reservoir into the Tampa Bay ecosystem, a move that could avoid disaster at the reservoir but could have harmful effects like red tide and fish kills in the Tampa Bay waters.
A team from the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers was assessing the structural integrity of the phosphogypsum stack’s containment pond wall Monday, Manatee County officials said.
As of Monday afternoon, the worstcase scenario – a total collapse of the earthen berm that would cause floodwater to inundate nearby properties – had been avoided, but the possible identification of additional weakness in the wall could be a concern.
Officials are in a race against time to pump enough of the toxic water out of the pond to alleviate pressure on breaches in the wall and avoid its collapse. Manatee County acting Administrator Scott Hopes said about 35 mil
lion gallons are being pumped out of the pond daily, but when additional pumps were operating later Monday that would increase to between 75 million and 100 million gallons daily.
“A leak in the containment wall continues at the Piney Point facility. ... The seepage rates remained steady overnight,” County Public Safety Director Jacob Saur said during a news conference Monday. “At approximately 2 a. m. an infrared drone identified a signature that could indicate a second breach.”
Engineers were “reassessing” the possible second breach, Saur said.
Saur said in a follow- up interview that officials can’t say for sure if the wall’s structural integrity has further deteriorated. “The engineers are not sure if they already knew about that second breach or not,” Saur said, adding, “It might be nothing.”
‘ We’re in a critical stage’
The containment pond held less than 300 million gallons Monday afternoon. Hopes said that within 48 hours “we will be at a situation where we will no longer have that risk of a full breach.” About 150 million to 200 million gallons need to be pumped to reach that point, Saur said.
But for now, county officials are urging people within the flood zone if the containment wall collapses to take the evacuation notice seriously.
“You need to take that evacuation message to heed,” Saur said. “We’re not out of the woods yet. We’re in a critical stage.”
More than 300 homes and multiple businesses in the area around Piney Point have been evacuated. The Manatee County Sheriff ’ s Office said 345 lowrisk jail inmates were moved to an undisclosed location because of concerns about floodwaters reaching the jail.
The review of the site Monday by the Army Corps is the first time an engineering team independent of the property owner, HRK Holdings, has analyzed the situation. Officials had been relying on a third- party engineering contractor hired by HRK.
U. S. Rep. Vern Buchanan, R- Fla., who toured the site via helicopter Monday, urged the Army Corps and the U. S. Department of Environmental Protection to get involved.
“I want the best and the brightest on the ground,” Buchanan said.
Buchanan said the problems at Piney Point were years in the making, and probably should have been dealt with earlier. “This is something that, unfortunately, could have been dealt with probably over the years, but I’m not looking to assess blame or anything else,” Buchanan said. “I’m here to do everything I can to help the county and I don’t think it’s just Manatee County, this impacts the region.”
Roughly 480 million gallons were being held in the containment pond before the leak started and officials began pumping water out on March 30.
The water being discharged has high levels of nutrients, such as nitrogen and phosphorous, and environmental advocates are concerned that it will fuel algae blooms that cause fish kills and other environmental damage.
The situation already is an environmental catastrophe, but it could still get worse if the containment wall collapses. “I want to be hopeful, optimistic,” Buchanan said. “But just the fact that we’re running water into Tampa Bay is not a great thing, it’s not a great place to be at.”
Gov. Ron DeSantis said during a press conference that emergency managers had deployed about 20 additional pumps in an effort to double the flow of water out of the pond.
“We are hoping that we can just continue to get the water out in an S way and prevent a catastrophic event, but we have to prepare that this could be something where you see further degradation,” DeSantis said.