Trump clamps lid on documents
He asserts executive privilege to keep census records secret
WASHINGTON – President Donald Trump asserted executive privilege Wednesday to keep secret the documents related to adding a citizenship question to the census as a House panel voted to hold two Cabinet members in contempt for defying subpoenas for the documents.
In a further escalation of conflicts between Congress and the administration, the Oversight and Reform Committee voted 24-15 to hold Attorney General William Barr and Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross in contempt for defying subpoenas for documents about how a citizenship question was added to the 2020 census.
The Judiciary Committee found Barr in contempt for defying a subpoena for the full report from special counsel Robert Mueller, who investigated Russian interference in the 2016 election.
The Constitution calls for the census to count everyone in the country every decade. The administration’s decision to ask people whether they are citizens in 2020 has been contentious because
of Democratic concerns it could discourage participation.
Republicans said the census included a citizenship question from 1820 to 1950, and the question appeared on more detailed questionnaires in recent decades.
Assistant Attorney General Stephen Boyd told Oversight Committee Chairman Elijah Cummings, D-Md., in a letter Wednesday that Trump asserted executive privilege to prevent the release of documents listed in the subpoena, including a Dec. 12, 2017, letter to the U.S. Census Bureau. Trump protectively asserted executive privilege over the rest of the subpoenaed documents while officials determine whether they should be kept secret.
“By proceeding with today’s vote, you have abandoned the accommodation process with respect to your requests and subpoenas for documents concerning the secretary’s decision to include a citizenship question on the 2020 Census,” Boyd said.
Trump declined to discuss the assertion of executive privilege Wednesday during a joint appearance at the White House with the president of Poland, but he defended the citizenship question.
“I think when you have a census, and you’re not allowed to talk about whether or not somebody is a citizen or not, that doesn’t sound so good to me,” Trump said. “So I don’t want to get you into this battle, but it’s ridiculous.”
Cummings said the committee needed to act because the administration refused to provide documents for multiple investigations, including the subpoenas about the census that were submitted two months ago.
“It appears to be another example of the administration’s blanket defiance,” Cummings said. “This begs the question: What is being hidden?”
Rep. Jim Jordan of Ohio, the top Republican on the committee, said Democrats were moving urgently on the contempt vote in an attempt to influence the Supreme Court, which is considering a case dealing with the census question.
“This is just another attempt to muddy the waters,” Jordan said. “It’s not what we should be doing.”
The census counts the population once a decade to apportion seats in Congress, providing figures to map House districts and contributing to enforcement of the Voting Rights Act by showing the Justice Department where minorities live. The population figures are used throughout government to divide billions in federal spending each year.
The Supreme Court, which called the census “the linchpin of the federal statistical system,” heard a case about the citizenship question in April, and a ruling is likely by the end of June. The court will decide whether Ross had ample reason to ask about citizenship, followed acceptable procedures and acted within the bounds of the Constitution.
Cummings said Tuesday that the administration refused to provide documents for a variety of inquiries dealing with hurricane recovery in Puerto Rico, White House security clearances and technology transfers to Saudi Arabia.
He said enforcing the subpoenas is critical to answering why Ross added the citizenship question, which Democrats fear will be used to intimidate minorities from responding to the oncea-decade count of the population.
“This is a broad, coordinated campaign to stonewall investigations across the board – and it is being directed from the very top,” Cummings said.
Trump said he will defy subpoenas because the multiple House inquiries amount to presidential harassment. House Republicans argued that Democrats are moving too hastily to find officials in contempt and to file federal lawsuits, rather than spending more time negotiating with the Justice Department for contested documents.
“The record before the committee does not support contempt of Congress at this time,” Jordan said Tuesday in a letter to Cummings. “If you were serious about getting to the facts on the Administration’s decision to reinstitute a citizenship question on the 2020 Census, you should attempt to obtain the information from other sources before rushing to contempt of Congress.”
The census fight followed a House vote Tuesday to authorize lawsuits to enforce subpoenas against Barr for the full Mueller report.
“This is a broad, coordinated campaign to stonewall investigations across the board – and it is being directed from the very top.”
Rep. Elijah Cummings, D-Md.
Elijah Cummings, top, leads the committee that voted to hold William Barr, center, and Wilbur Ross in contempt.
Rep. Jim Jordan, R-Ohio, accuses House Oversight Committee Chairman Elijah Cummings, right, of “rushing to contempt of Congress.”