Android Advisor

Best camera phones

Having a first-class camera is a must for many when picking a new phone. Here are our favourites.

- ALEX WALKER-TODD reports

Camera quality has become one of the biggest points of considerat­ion when choosing a new smartphone. The arms race for sharper and smarter cameras in the sliver of glass, metal and silicon that resides in your pocket is easily one of the most heated right now.

As such, it’s pushing manufactur­ers to create hardware capable of astounding image and video

quality, despite the limited amount of space and size they have to work with.

We’ve collated a shortlist of the best Android camera phones currently on the market, based on the latest and greatest smartphone­s to run through our review gauntlet.

How we test phone cameras

Rather than using controlled conditions and attempting to compare the cameras scientific­ally, we take photos and videos just as anyone else would, in real-world situations, without additional equipment such as a tripod, extra lenses or a dedicated flash.

We drill down to test out manual controls, may alter still or recording resolution to draw comparison­s and make sure to test any specialist or dedicated features or settings a particular device boasts too.

1. Google Pixel 4/4 XL

Price: Google Pixel 4 (64GB)

£499 from fave.co/2BXNZrN

Price: Google Pixel 4 XL (64GB)

£659 from fave.co/3fbQjdf

Like their predecesso­rs, the Google Pixel 4 and 4 XL share the same camera arrangemen­t.

Despite finally integratin­g a second sensor into the main module, the hardware at play isn’t particular­ly fancy by current smartphone standards; on the surface, it lacks lustre, compared to the photograph­ic set-ups of key rivals. But there’s more to the Pixel 4 series’ imaging chops than its hardware.

As with previous-generation Pixels, Google’s ‘Computatio­nal Photograph­y’ and the Neural Core (the successor to the Pixel 3-series’ Visual Core) chip allow for outstandin­g image processing, resulting in superb final photos and videos.

The main camera still relies on the same 12.2Mp Sony IMX363 sensor as the last two Pixel lines, but now also incorporat­es a secondary 16Mp telephoto sensor too, which offers up to 2x lossless optical zoom. Perhaps more importantl­y, the secondary sensor also helps with the phones depth perception when judging portrait imagery.

Software features are the highlights here: Super Res Zoom, Night Sight and Top Shot. Super Res Zoom takes several photos and uses the slight difference­s between frames at capture, along with Google’s computing

power, to intelligen­tly ‘create’ pixels for a better-quality zoomed photo than mere interpolat­ion would create.

Night Sight works in a similar way to create a correctly exposed image rather than one which is too dark. It’s possible to get some fantastic results in dark conditions so long as there’s no movement in the scene beyond your shaky hands.

To up the ante, Google has also added a new astrophoto­graphy mode, letting you capture stars and planets in the night sky, provided the phone remains still long enough and there’s minimal light pollution. While a niche feature, it’s a unique inclusion that helps the Pixel 4 camera stand out.

Top Shot shoots a series of photos and automatica­lly selects the best one, eliminatin­g any images where a person’s eyes were shut or someone wasn’t smiling.

In good light, the Pixel 4’s photos are just as amazing as you’d expect. Detail is crisp, white balance excellent and dynamic range is impressive. This is also the first time you have the option to adjust the highlights and darker regions of exposure independen­tly in real-time.

Portrait shots are very good, with authentic-looking bokeh (background blur). Even with the second sensor though, it should be said that errors around the edge of a subject still have the potential to appear.

It’s also worth noting that, despite finally adopting a secondary sensor, opting for an ultra wide-angle feels like it would have made more sense, compared to a telephoto. Super Res Zoom on the singlesens­ored Pixel 3 line was already very good and the

2x magnificat­ion of the telephoto lens doesn’t add all that much, while capturing a wider field of view is one trait that can’t be achieved by software and image processing alone.

Speaking of wide angle – be aware that Google nixed the secondary ultra-wide front-face from last year’s Pixel 3 line to incorporat­e the new phone’s Motion Sense smarts.

Generally speaking, video quality remains unchanged from the Pixel 2 and Pixel 3, still maxing out at 4K/30fps. Stabilizat­ion is a combinatio­n of electronic and optical and works at all resolution­s. It’s

a shame that 60fps isn’t available at 4K and that Google still hasn’t improved the slo-mo options: you’re still limited to 120fps at 1080p and can only shoot 240fps at 720p. However, the Pixel 4 does allow for zooming using that secondary sensor while recording and offers notable better audio capture compared to the Pixel 3.

Although you can criticize Google for certain decisions about the Pixel 4’s cameras and capabiliti­es, the main camera still takes outstandin­g photos and decent video.

2. Huawei P30 Pro

Price: £595 from fave.co/302kv4m

Despite the challenges Huawei continues to face against the US government and the entity list, you can’t deny that it makes some excellent phones.

The impressive P20 Pro first proved that Huawei was serious about making a competitiv­e camera phone – a point it then reinforced with the Mate 20 Pro later that same year. Then, the P30 Pro arrived and has subsequent­ly continued to push the envelope with its quad-camera array.

The standout feature has to be its 5x optical zoom but there’s also an impressive amount of megapixels to play with, ultra-wide capture and even dedicated depth-sensing on offer.

One of the advantages of this system is that the P30 Pro is able to use its main camera for portrait photos and therefore offers the same field of view. Most of its rivals have to crop in, which while not a damning problem, can be a bit irritating.

However, it’s that zoom system that really ‘wows’. If you think a 2x telephoto lens is adequate, you’ll quickly change that opinion once you’ve used the P30 Pro’s 5x telephoto lens.

The P30 Pro uses a hybrid zoom system that leans on the megapixel clout of the main 40Mp sensor, along with the base image quality of the 8Mp sensor attached to the periscopic arrangemen­t to achieve what Huawei describes as ‘lossless 10x zoom’.

It’s a different way of doing things to Google’s Super Res Zoom and a methodolog­y we think is more effective overall. Despite the claims though, it’s obvious from looking at photos at 1:1 that to call it ‘lossless’ is somewhat of a misnomer. Close scrutiny aside, it’s impossible not to be impressed by the detail the P30 Pro can capture. In our sample shots, there’s a surprising amount of detail and clarity in the 10x zoom

photos. Even at 5x, the P30 Pro still blows the majority of the competitio­n out of the water.

By default, Master AI – the ‘artificial intelligen­ce’ image processing – is switched off, and for the most part, you’ll probably leave it that way. There’s still a tendency to over-saturate everything when it’s on but not to the extent that it did on the P20 Pro.

Beyond the party piece, the phone’s 40Mp ‘Super Sensing’ primary camera also impresses. Huawei ditched a traditiona­l RGB pixel arrangemen­t for two yellow sub-pixels instead of green (RYYB). That’s because yellow is more sensitive to light, allowing the sensor to capture up to 40 per cent more light.

In addition to taking sharp, detailed images during the day, it’s possible to shoot astounding photos in the dark, even if you have shaky hands. The Night mode works in a similar way to the P20 Pro’s, combining a selection of photos over a varying period of time, depending on if the phone is mounted or handheld.

The main camera is the one to use for the majority of the time as it delivers the best photos. On the sample phone Huawei provided for our tests, photos from the ultra-wide camera presented noticeably different colours to those from the main and telephoto cameras; being

darker and more saturated. This issue is most annoying when you’re shooting video and you switch from the main camera to ultra wide, as the colours visibly shift.

The Apple-like interface of the camera app is also easy to use but is packed with a few too many settings and features.

The P30 Pro is Huawei’s first phone to offer stabilizat­ion in 4K, but there’s still no option to record it at 60fps. Video quality is very good, with lots of detail and good stereo sound. Stabilizat­ion isn’t great in 4K, sadly, so you may want to stick to 1080p or invest in a phone gimbal if you’re considerin­g the P30 Pro as the means to kick-start your YouTube career.

The 32Mp front-facer does undoubtedl­y take a good selfie, but we couldn’t see a whole lot more detail compared to the P20 Pro’s 24Mp offering. Look up close and details appear ‘smeary’, with heavy noise reduction evidently at work. It also seems that even with the slider set to zero, beauty processing is still going on to some small degree.

While the P30 Pro isn’t perfect, the ultra-wide and zoom cameras each have their flaws, but overall the versatilit­y on offer here let’s you capture shots that simply aren’t possible on other devices. Did we mention its excellent low light capabiliti­es?

3. Samsung Galaxy Note 10+

Price: £849 from fave.co/2l77Bla

The Note 10+’s cameras are quite different from that of their predecesso­r. Instead of minor tweaks, Samsung has added a third imaging sensor to accompany the

12Mp main and 12Mp telephoto snappers. This latest addition is an ultra-wide 16Mp sensor, meaning the Note series now totes more versatilit­y than ever before. The Note 10+ also incorporat­es a 3D ToF sensor for better depth perception and Air Gesture remote control support, using the included S Pen stylus.

The main camera is similar to what you’d find on the Galaxy S10 and other recent Samsung flagships. Its iris can switch between two apertures: f/1.5 (bigger) and f/2.4 (smaller), offering greater management over available light and photo quality as a result. The telephoto camera is also the same, with a 2x zoom and optical stabilizat­ion, while the 16Mp sensor has a 35mm equivalent of 13mm with an f/2.4 aperture.

Considerin­g its predecesso­r, it’s no surprise to see similarly good quality from the Note 10+’s photos. They have great dynamic range, so there’s lots of detail in

both shadows and highlights. Auto HDR means you don’t have to think about exposure, either.

White balance is generally reliable, so colours are very good in just about all lighting except when it’s really dark. Zoom in on a big screen and there’s a lack of sharp, fine detail but this is a minor complaint. You won’t notice the effect of the variable aperture, as it’ll mainly stick to f/2.4 in daylight.

The 2x zoom works well enough but obviously can’t compete with the P30 Pro’s or Oppo Reno 10x Zoom’s magnificat­ion. As with the main camera, exposure, white balance and colours are very good.

Images shot with the ultra-wide camera lack detail when you zoom in, but there’s no obvious drop-off in sharpness as you often find at the edges of the lens.

In portrait mode, the Note 10+ uses the same field of view as the main camera and does a good job of depth detection, helped by that additional 3D ToF sensor. There’s a more realistic gradient to the blurring from foreground to background that makes the Note 10’s portrait photos more convincing than from other phones. That said, it still has a tough time adequately isolating wisps of hair, as any close examinatio­n will reveal.

For video, the Note 10+ offers great ‘Super Steady’ (digital) stabilizat­ion – letting you capture handheld footage that looks as though it was shot on a stabilized gimbal. Live focus is also pretty impressive, as it can isolate a moving subject in-frame and add real-time background blur if desired.

Overall, the Note 10+ has excellent cameras. It takes wonderful photos in good light, which are on par with the best here. Its strengths include great portrait modes for both front and rear cameras, and great video stabilizat­ion (plus the ability to record in HDR10+).

The zoom is much more limited than the P30 Pro’s, as are the Note 10+’s low light capabiliti­es. But if you

prefer to buy Samsung rather than Huawei, the latest Note is a fine choice.

4. Oppo Reno 10x Zoom

Price: £649 from fave.co/2ZYMMbE The Reno 10x Zoom feels a lot like the superb OnePlus 7 Pro but trades that phone’s phenomenal screen for a better camera instead – a trade-off that’s likely to make sense for a lot of people. It’s got top specs, a decent battery and a slick design – as long as you don’t mind the ‘shark fin’.

As you might be able to guess from the name, the camera is the star of the show here. The flagship Reno boasts a triple-lens set-up with an

optically-stabilized (OIS) 48Mp, f/1.7 primary lens, backed up by an ultra-wide 8Mp sensor and a 13Mp sensor with 5x optical zoom.

Despite this transverse 5x optical zoom, the phone promises 10x hybrid zoom, similarly to Huawei’s P30 Pro and a maximum 60x magnificat­ion overall.

The imaging team responsibl­e for tuning the Reno’s camera has done an excellent job, granting you some of the best stills possible from the IMX586 sensor that’s used by a whole handful of current-gen handsets.

In the case of the Reno 10x Zoom, it shoots with a natural-looking warmth, pleasing dynamic range and it trumps other similarly-specified phone cameras with regards to general versatilit­y; namely devices like Xiaomi’s Mi 9 and the aforementi­oned OnePlus 7 Pro.

Its low-light capabiliti­es are also top-notch, considerin­g the sensor at play, with only Huawei’s, Apple’s and Google’s latest and greatest really standing out in front.

One of the most visually striking aspects of the Reno 10x Zoom has to be the ‘pivot rising camera’ that sits flush to the phone’s top edge when not in use. Whether you’re using the main shooter with the flash on, or you want to snap a selfie, the ‘shark fin’ will pop up and greet you.

As pop-up cameras go, this design looks like one of the more reliable, based on its engineerin­g, with a 16Mp sensor on offer that takes decent enough selfies, provided you aren’t looking for anything mind-blowing.

 ??  ??
 ??  ?? Google has added a 16Mp lens to the main 12.2Mp sensor
Google has added a 16Mp lens to the main 12.2Mp sensor
 ??  ?? Image taken using the main camera
Image taken using the main camera
 ??  ?? …and this the 8x zoom
…and this the 8x zoom
 ??  ?? This was taken using the 2x zoom…
This was taken using the 2x zoom…
 ??  ?? The Night Sight creates a correctly exposed image rather than one which is too dark
The Night Sight creates a correctly exposed image rather than one which is too dark
 ??  ?? Portrait shots are very good, with authentic-looking bokeh
Portrait shots are very good, with authentic-looking bokeh
 ??  ?? The phone’s low light shots are also impressive
The phone’s low light shots are also impressive
 ??  ?? The Huawei P30 Pro’s standout feature is its 5x optical zoom
The Huawei P30 Pro’s standout feature is its 5x optical zoom
 ??  ?? The phone’s 40Mp ‘Super Sensing’ primary camera produces impressive results
The phone’s 40Mp ‘Super Sensing’ primary camera produces impressive results
 ??  ?? …and here’s another using the 10x zoom
…and here’s another using the 10x zoom
 ??  ?? Here’s an image taken using the 5x zoom…
Here’s an image taken using the 5x zoom…
 ??  ?? The Night Mode combines a selection of photos over a varying period of time
The Night Mode combines a selection of photos over a varying period of time
 ??  ?? Here’s an example of a wide-angle shot
Here’s an example of a wide-angle shot
 ??  ?? The 32Mp front-facing lens takes good selfies
The 32Mp front-facing lens takes good selfies
 ??  ?? The phone takes excellent shots in low light
The phone takes excellent shots in low light
 ??  ?? Samsung has added a third camera to the rear of the Note 10+
Samsung has added a third camera to the rear of the Note 10+
 ??  ?? The telephoto lens was used to take this photo
The telephoto lens was used to take this photo
 ??  ?? Here’s a shot taken using the main lens
Here’s a shot taken using the main lens
 ??  ?? Images shot with the ultra-wide camera lack detail when you zoom in
Images shot with the ultra-wide camera lack detail when you zoom in
 ??  ?? Portrait photos are more convincing than from other phones
Portrait photos are more convincing than from other phones
 ??  ?? You won’t be surprised to hear that the Oppo Reno has a 10x zoom lens
You won’t be surprised to hear that the Oppo Reno has a 10x zoom lens
 ??  ?? …and this one uses the 6x zoom
…and this one uses the 6x zoom
 ??  ?? This picture is a standard shot…
This picture is a standard shot…
 ??  ?? Finally, here’s an image using the 60x zoom
Finally, here’s an image using the 60x zoom
 ??  ?? Here’s the same scene shot using the 10x zoom
Here’s the same scene shot using the 10x zoom
 ??  ?? The Oppo’s low-light shots are top-notch
The Oppo’s low-light shots are top-notch
 ??  ?? You’ll be pleased with the quality of the Oppo’s selfie shots
You’ll be pleased with the quality of the Oppo’s selfie shots

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Australia