Driver fined over fatality
Prosecutors drop intoxication charge against garbo who killed Deakin student
NEW York garbage truck driver Felipe Chairez, who drank beer before the Central Park West bicycle crash that killed Geelong resident Madison Lyden, has walked out of court with $1390 in fines after prosecutors dismissed the main charge.
Assistant District Attorney Anne Siegel told a hearing in Manhattan on Tuesday “the evidence is insufficient” to prove beyond a reasonable doubt a charge of operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated against Chairez.
Witnesses and video confirmed Chairez drove his truck in his lane, within the speed limit and in a reasonable manner, she said.
“All known eyewitnesses, including the victim’s friend who was cycling close behind her at the time she was killed, were spoken to,” Ms Siegel said.
Ms Lyden, 23, was raised in Tasmania and had been working and studying in Geelong. She was holidaying in New York on August 10 last year.
She was riding a bike along Central Park West near West 67th Street when an Uber driver allegedly strayed into her bike lane, forcing Ms Lyden to swerve into Chairez’s truck.
Ms Lyden’s mother, Amanda Berry, was furious the Uber driver wasn’t charged.
The NYPD also wanted the Uber driver charged, but Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance said “a gap in the law” meant he could not because state law did not allow for a criminal charge of a driver who has not made contact with other vehicles or people.
Chairez, according to police, said he drank two beers before the incident. Police said he had a 0.04 blood-alcohol reading.
Chairez entered guilty pleas on Tuesday to one count of operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs and one count of operating a motor vehicle while impaired by alcohol.
He was sentenced to $695 fines for each count, a oneyear driver's licence suspension and ordered to attend a victim impact panel and the Stop DWI Program.
Prosecutors said they spoke with two men who were with Chairez before he drove from his last job site in downtown Manhattan north towards the Bronx and who were in a compartment in the garbage truck at the time of the incident.
“Witnesses at 66-67th streets and Central Park West stated the defendant remained in his lane and drove within the speed limit,” Ms Siegel said.