Review: Windows 10 20H1
Price: Free update
Our review of Microsoft’s Windows 10 20H1 update – also known as version 2004, or perhaps the Windows 10 April 2020 Update – shows an operating system focused primarily on building out existing features, rather than launching new ones. Some scaffolding is still apparent in tweaks to Your Phone and especially Cortana. Microsoft has further polished Task Manager, Settings and Game
Bar, however, and isn’t afraid to serve niche audiences with upgrades to the Windows Subsystem for Linux and the related Terminal app.
As in the past, we’ve based our review on Microsoft’s Windows 10 20H1 Insider builds, beginning with the major features and working through to its minor additions. Though Microsoft essentially signalled that the 20H1 release was finished by January, we waited until the end of February to complete our tests. It’s important to note, however, that Microsoft hasn’t announced when the ‘final’ 20H1 version will ship, and a few more bugs may be fixed before then.
Meet the Windows Subsystem for Linux 2, and Terminal
When Microsoft introduced the Windows Subsystem for Linux (WSL) as part of the Windows 10 Anniversary Update in 2016, it was a shock to see Microsoft embrace Linux after opposing it for so many years. But the original Windows Subsystem for Linux was hobbled by the fact that it wasn’t running a real Linux kernel. Certain kernel modules, such as device drivers, were unable to run.
With WSL2, Linux now runs on its own kernel, in what’s essentially a virtual machine. If you use Linux, you’ll also be able to place your Linux files within the Linux root file system, and access them via Windows File Explorer inside the Linux virtual hard disk. Consequently, performance is expected to improve, one of the key upgrades for WSL2 over WSL1.
To set it up, you’ll need to enable Windows’ Linux capabilities manually via the ‘Turn Windows
features on and off’ panel. Linux is free, conveniently available from the Microsoft Store as one of a number of downloadable distributions including Ubuntu and Debian, and relatively easy to set up. (Converting your existing distro over from WSL1 to WSL2 is relatively simple, too. Simply type
wsl – set-version
And yes, there’s a new Windows Terminal app. The Command Line served as a DOS shell for years, allowing you to navigate Windows and run various commands. Now Terminal stands in as a command-line interface for DOS, PowerShell and Linux, with multiple configurable tabs to run any of them side by side.
You’re still free to run a BASH shell from within a Linux application like Ubuntu, but Terminal’s designed to be the preferred way to run Linux within Windows.
That’s because Linux under WSL2 is largely textbased. While there are methods to enable a Linux GUI, most require some interaction between WSL2 and Windows 10, and a remote connection between the two. By and large, WSL2 is designed for text-editing apps like vim and emacs, according to Microsoft employees working on WSL2, as well as text-based ‘apps’ like Nethack, as Microsoft’s own tutorial shows off (fave.co/2VYlFgz).
Terminal’s clean, modern, pleasant to use, and doesn’t get in your way – all prerequisites for a text editor. But it’s not perfect, either: for one thing, how functions are split between PowerShell, the Command
Prompt, and Linux is confusing. Why does enabling the paned view below require the command to be entered into the Command Line box, rather than PowerShell? It may be obvious to an advanced user, but not to one who’s new to the environment.
If you’re willing to dig into the multitude of tips, guides, and other documentation around the Web, WSL2 is simple to use. (Just remember that Linux commands and files aren’t isolated from Windows in the way Windows Sandbox is, so be careful.) All told, the combination of WSL2 and the new Terminal app spruces up the interface and delivers a bit more power under the hood.
Cortana dumbs down as it becomes an app
Remember last year, when Microsoft separated Windows Search and Cortana, once co-located within the same search box, into two separate functions? Now, Cortana’s left entirely. Cortana is now a windowed app
that can be undocked, moved around your desktop, and resized at will. Microsoft has also returned Cortana’s ability to receive requests via text as well as voice.
This change has pluses and minuses. When Cortana was integrated with the taskbar, the assistant had a tendency to disappear when you returned focus to another window. This made sense in certain cases, but when you asked a question, you had to copy down the answer before doing anything else. Currently, Cortana seems to disappear as a window if it’s on your primary screen and you begin interacting with another window. On a secondary monitor, though, the window remains.
Cortana now allows you to specify whether you’d like to talk to Cortana or simply type responses in its in-app Settings menu. That’s somewhat handy, although at that point Cortana becomes less of an assistant and just another search box. Microsoft also says its changed the ‘wake word’ to just ‘Cortana’. The distinction is largely academic: On my build, Cortana didn’t respond to a wake word at all, even after double-checking that the mic was properly set up. Clicking the mic button (or the Win+C shortcut) did trigger Cortana, however, and the speech recognition was usually good.
Cortana’s functionality has suffered. There’s no Windows 10 Settings area that controls the app, just general speech controls. While Windows can be governed by a personal account and connect to a business account, there’s no obvious way to do that with Cortana – you have to pick one or the other, which is sort of awkward.
On my test build, Cortana was unable to launch Amazon’s Alexa in-app, as it’s done previously.
(We know now there will be an enormous loss of Cortana functionality, including IoT controls like the Harman Invoke, Spotify controls, and more. Microsoft representatives tell us that the calculator functions and other skills will be added back, supposedly by the time 20H1 ships to users.)
At some point, Cortana is supposed to evolve into a ‘conversational’ assistant, like the Google Assistant. If
I ask Google the height of the Eiffel Tower, then follow up by asking ‘where is it’, Google understands that I mean the same tower. Cortana doesn’t.
On the other hand, if I ask Cortana to send an emailed note to my wife, Cortana will ask for confirmation before it’s sent. Replying ‘no’ prompted it to ask me what I wanted to change: the recipient, the message or something else. That’s the sort of conversational interaction Microsoft seems to be shooting for, but examples of this seem to be few and far between. Cortana’s ability to understand is also improving, as it parsed “What did the Dow Jones do today?” correctly.
While I know separating Cortana into its own app allows for improvements to be made independently and at their own pace, our current testing shows (and Microsoft confirms) that Cortana is failing to meet the basic requirements of a digital assistant.
Fresh new icons signal the future
I’ve always been of two minds on cosmetic updates: I tend to strongly favour function over form, but I despise Brutalist architecture. Aesthetics does play a role.
Microsoft’s begun rolling out a stable of updated icons to Windows, and it looks like those will be appearing in the 2004/20H1 build, too. They provide a new, cohesive design language to Windows 10 and it looks like they’ll be a unifying element for Windows 10X and possibly subsequent versions of Windows 10.
Any new icon updates have the advantage of looking fresh, and they’re consistent with Microsoft’s Fluent Design principles. (For more, see Microsoft’s
blog post, fave.co/3cUmeyj.) It’s very likely that we’re seeing the end of the road for Microsoft’s tiled interface, and a return to a more icon-driven UI.
New emoji and kaomoji
Even though it’s not forced upon you, the emoji/ kaomoji keyboard that’s accessible via the Win+; shortcut is one of the more useful additions to Windows over the past few feature releases. Now, there are a few new additions to the pane, courtesy of Emoji 12, with icons that include an otter, ballet shoes, and more.
Kaomoji – more complex representations of various symbols that combine punctuation marks – have been enhanced as well. So while the basic kaomoji include representations of the ‘shruggie’ , ¯\_( )_/¯ there’s also been some new additions including the wizard ( ^o^) and whatever this is: _ . The emoji toolbar
still disappears when you’re not using it, though. It would be nice to have a toggle where it could remain on your screen at all times.
Your Phone is now (almost) fully operational
The Windows 10 Your Phone app has been slowly adding additional functionality across several Windows feature releases, and it’s arguably nearing completion. But the experience is still fragmented among various devices.
With the right combination of phone and PC, the Your Phone app on Windows can now show recent photos shot with the phone, view and send SMS
messages, be alerted with the phone’s notifications, see the phone’s battery life, view and interact with the phone screen and apps, and even make calls. (Phones require the Your Phone Companion app to establish the connection.) It’s worth reading our earlier Your Phone tutorial to learn how each feature works – see Tech
Advisor, February 2020, page 83.
Subtle UI touches have crept in, such as indicators for unread messages or notifications, and built-in GIF and picture support within the Messages component. Some aspects could use some polishing: I still can get redundant notifications from both Windows as well as Your Phone if someone messages me, for example.
The reality, however, is that Your Phone’s functionality still varies by device, PC, and connection. With a OnePlus 6T connected to a Surface Laptop 3 running a Windows 10 20H1 build, my Your Phone app included all of the functionality listed above, save for my ability to interact with my phone’s screen. Ditto for a Google Pixel 3XL.
The ability to interact with the smartphone screen under Your Phone also depends on whether you own a PC with Bluetooth that supports a low-energy peripheral role, like the Surface Book 2 I used to create the Your Phone tutorial. Desktop PCs often don’t
have Bluetooth. Meanwhile, Samsung phones require their own app, called Link to Windows, to establish a connection. Oh, and Apple iPhones? They’re pretty much out of the loop entirely.
I don’t want to sell Your Phone short – there’s quite a lot there. Like many Windows apps, Your Phone isn’t a necessary part of your workflow, but a convenience that allows you to interact with texts and notifications easily, without breaking your workflow to pull out your phone. It’s true, too, that the basic photos/messages/ notifications/calls functionality should be in play for a majority of Android users as the 20H1 release rolls out.