Thai PM wins crucial legal battle
THAI Prime Minister Pray ut Chano-cha sur v ived a lega l challenge on December 2 over his liv ing arrangements t hat cou ld have seen h i m thrown out of office, in a court ruling t hat prompted a nger a mong t housands of pro-democracy protesters.
The kingdom’s nine-judge constitutional court ruled that Prayut – already under pressure after months of street protests calling for him to quit – was not guilty of conflict of interest by living in an army residence after leaving the military.
Thousands of protesters defied a warning from the court to respect its ruling, taking to the streets to condemn the verdict as unjust.
The court ruled that Prayut’s status as prime minister entitled him to live in the military house even though he stepped down as army chief in 2014.
The head justice said: “The status of Genera l Pray ut Cha n-o-cha a s prime minister and defence minister remains unchanged.”
Though widely expected, the ruling angered the protest movement that has shaken Thailand since July, calling for Prayut, who came to power in a 2014 coup, to quit.
Some 5,000 protesters massed at a major intersection in northern Bangkok. The rally included uniformed high school students wearing hair clips shaped like rubber ducks, a symbol of the pro-democracy movement.
“I ’m n o t s u r p r i s e d b e c a u s e
I think the court received the directive from the top. The court is not fair,” Reeda, 26, a graduate student, said as demonstrators gathered at Lat Phrao intersection.
“In the past they always decide decisions that contrast with the feeling of the people.”
On the eve of the decision the court warned against “vulgar” criticism of its work, but this did not deter protesters, who daubed slogans against the court and Prayut on the road.
“I know the prime minister will always be okay – it’s like the same mafia running things in Thailand. But many people know the tr uth,” Chat, a 60-year-old retiree, said.
Prominent student leader Par i t “Penguin” Chiwarak addressed the crowd on a stage with a mocked-up model of the constitutional court as a backdrop.
He told the rally: “I propose that Thailand has no need for this constitutional court. They must all go. They have thwarted democracy far too many times.
“[ The judges are] appointed by Prayut so they work for Prayut, not us the people. They no longer have legitimacy in our justice system.”
The case against Prayut was brought by the main opposition party Pheu Thai, and if it had succeeded, the prime minister and his cabinet would have been thrown out of office.
The court said the military had changed the status of the residence from an army house to a guest house in 2012 “so technically, the defendant’s no longer living inside an army house”.
The premier has previously argued his family must stay at the army house on a military base for security reasons.
After the verdict, government spokesman Anucha Burapachaisri said Prayut was “working as usual and following his official schedule as normal”.
He appeared relaxed ahead of the decision, and toured a coconut farm on December 2, sending his lawyers to hear the verdict on his behalf.
Titipol Phakdeewanich, a political scientist with Ubon Ratchathani University, said Prayut’s victory was little surprise.
He told AFP: “They always try to find a legal loophole to protect him.”
Chulalongkorn University political scientist Thitinan Pongsudhirak echoed the view.
He told AFP: “Anyone who’s followed Thai politics for the past 15 years will think it’s a f o re g o n e c o n c l u s i o n . . . because the constitutional court has been so politicised since 2006 that it does not engender public trust.”
The pro-democracy movement is facing legal action of its own, with five key leaders charged on November 30 under Thailand’s strict royal defamation laws – the first time they have been used in two years.
As well as calling for Prayut to go, protesters also want a rewrite of the army-drafted constitution and for reforms to the monarchy – a taboosmashing demand in a country where the ultra-wealthy royal family has long been untouchable.