Feds tout internal trade deal
Internal trade deal removes barriers, creates better options for labour mobility
TORONTO After 150 years of squabbling over internal trade, Canadians finally have a comprehensive internal trade agreement — and they might have Europe to thank for it.
The federal government, 10 provinces and three territories on Friday in Toronto unveiled the Canadian Free Trade Agreement, a deal that commits them to remove all internal barriers on trade — except for 144 specific exemptions claimed by one of the 14 member governments. The deal replaces the 1995 Agreement on Internal Trade, which opened up business only in the 11 sectors covered in that pact.
Government procurement is a big part of the new deal. Suppliers and service providers can now bid on government business outside their home provinces.
This isn’t a coincidence. The new trade deal with the European Union, the Canada-EU Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement, opens government procurement to transatlantic competition. Had Canada’s internal trade deal failed to open up government procurement, European bidders would have had better access to bid for federal contracts.
“Without the new Canadian Free Trade Agreement, we could have seen a circumstance where EU companies were getting greater ac- cess to the Canadian market than homegrown companies,” said Brad Duguid, Ontario’s minister of economic development and growth. “That just didn’t make sense to any of us.”
“This is really about Canada strengthening its home-field advantage,” said Navdeep Bains, federal minister of innovation, science and economic development. “At the federal level, we’re making significant investments in infrastructure, $180 billion over the next 10 years. That procurement will be open to all businesses across the country.”
Labour mobility is another big part of the agreement. Licensed professionals and trades people accredited in one province, such as engineers or carpenters, will be allowed to work in another province without having to re-qualify with the local regulator.
The agreement also opens the power generation sector and permits energy utilities to compete for business across provincial lines.
The deal sets up a “negative list” regime in which all trade moves are free unless one of the 14 governments declares an exemption. The list is already long. The exemptions — one reporter counted 144 — take up 135 pages of the 335-page pact.
It will come as little surprise that alcohol — an item that always comes up in discussions of Canada’s internal trade barriers — features prominently in the list of exemptions. Yet the deal does not shut the door to future liberalization. The deal gives the federal government, provinces and territories one year to come up with recommendations on how to enhance internal trade on wine, beer, and spirits.
The deal does, however, lay the groundwork for talks to establish a process to help provinces and territories regulate the trade of recreational pot. “We’ve seen 100 to 150 years of acrimony and debate about the availability of alcohol across the country,” said Duguid. “We do have an opportunity, I believe, to get (marijuana regulation) right from the start.”
Other issues are also subject to future talks. At some point in the next six months, the governments say they’ll discuss how to include financial services in the deal. Other working groups will tackle outstanding issues on fisheries and food.
Bains said even if there are a lot of exemptions, they’re outweighed by the general market access. “Everything is under the spotlight,” he said. “That puts a great deal of pressure on different jurisdictions to explain why they are looking for certain exemptions.”
Duguid, who until Friday chaired the internal trade negotiations, said CFTA improves on the 1995 agreement by building greater transparency into the deal.
“In many ways, this turns the old agreement upside down on its head,” he said. “Any province that has a concern about putting something on the table has to transparently put that in the agreement. That changes the whole dynamic. It’s put us in a position where now the entire economy is covered.”
If a recent study by the Bank of Canada is correct, removal of interprovincial trade barriers within Canada could add between 0.1 and 0.2 percentage points, or between $2 billion and $4 billion, to the country’s annual gross domestic product. Duguid was even more optimistic about the deal’s impact, saying it is expected to add $25 billion a year to the economy.
The central bank also suggests that if the removal of internal trade barriers is combined with three other big projects, the Trans-Pacific Partnership, the CETA deal, and the federal government’s infrastructure spending plan, the total effect could raise real Canadian GDP by three to five per cent or up to $100 billion by 2025.
Any province that has a concern about putting something on the table has to transparently put that in the agreement.