Edmonton Journal

State of mind is a matter of opinion

-

Is it reasonable to expect the same diplomatic behaviour from Donald Trump as would be expected of a president who came up through the ranks and is familiar with protocol, political lingo and diplomacy (hypocrisy and obscuranti­sm)?

It isn’t clear if it was on the basis of his actions or attitude, substance or form, that prompted a large group of psychiatri­sts to sign a document recommendi­ng his removal from office. This action was challenged by a brave psychiatri­st who pointed out that “compos mentis” could only be establishe­d on the basis of “habeas corpus.”

No one suggested, of course, that the psychiatri­sts themselves should first be observed, but Dostoevsky, weighing in on the issue over a hundred years ago in The Brothers Karamazov, noted that for every psychiatri­c opinion proffered concerning the accused’s state of mind, another psychiatri­c opinion could be found to refute it. Doris Wrench Eisler, St. Albert

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada