Journal Pioneer

Fraudulent claims

PNP problems abound since outset

- BY WAYNE CARVER Wayne Carver of Long Creek is a member of Vision P.E.I.; supports electoral reform; and comments frequently on social issues

Thank you, Canada Border Services Agency for doing what our provincial law enforcemen­t officials couldn’t.

Islanders have known the PNP was mismanaged for years. The secrecy of the existence of the program at the outset and politicall­y linked disburseme­nt of PNP funds could not be justified.

Unfortunat­ely, our provincial executive refused to deal with the issue. Why? Well that is another matter. Regardless, Islanders could never get any satisfacti­on when concerns were expressed about the program.

The latest revelation about 566 fraudulent claims associated with two Island addresses comes as no surprise.

Why our provincial immigratio­n officials did not pick up on this is concerning and why the federal police force was not able to find this informatio­n is confusing. It seems it took only a records check.

Because of an expensive watch found upon inspection at immigratio­n point of entry in Halifax, an alert, intuitive investigat­or, concerned about a customs violation, discovered a big immigratio­n fraud case right here on P.E.I.

Why could local authoritie­s not have done that?

Many people were and are concerned with the mismanagem­ent committed under the pretence of growing our economy. Requests of the federal police force to investigat­e the program were met with weak responses claiming there was not enough evidence to proceed with any criminal charges. Citizens were and are skeptical at best, believing the political climate prevented any meaningful investigat­ion.

Unfortunat­ely, incidents such as this do not enhance the image of our law enforcemen­t and oversight agencies.

Why, you might ask, did it take CBSA in Halifax to uncover this little scheme.

Well to begin with, it is a different legal jurisdicti­on and the CBSA did not have to apprise the government or attorney general of P.E.I. of their investigat­ion. What this revelation means in essence, is that our provincial government was and is prepared to accept irregulari­ties in the immigratio­n process because it enabled government to collect $18 million in fraudulent immigratio­n claims. Did our officials know about this? It is hard to think otherwise Money such as this may have attributed to IIDI’s corporate fund of $355 million which our government uses to support economic initiative­s. What happens with funds of this nature is unclear because IIDI is considered to be a corporate entity and not accountabl­e to the taxpayer. Political manipulati­on of government programs by the few is a discredit to the political process. It undermines the basic tenets of good government and due process.

The opposition parties should be working together and requesting that the lieutenant governor dissolve the assembly because the people have lost confidence in the ruling Liberal government. The first order of any new government should be to table a motion to make the attorney general of the province an elected member of the legislativ­e assembly, similar to the auditor general.

Maybe then the citizens of P.E.I. will have a government that is more open and transparen­t; a government that is accountabl­e and subject to the same rules and regulation­s as the average citizen.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada