Ottawa should go further in offering pardons for pot possession

The Trudeau government deserves only half a cheer for promising to make it easier for people convicted of minor cannabis-related offences to obtain pardons.

Now that cannabis has been legalized in this country, it’s the very least the government could do to redress the injustice for the estimated 500,000 Canadians who have a criminal record for possessing pot.

But we won’t offer a truly enthusiastic round of applause because the pardon measures announced last week by Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale don’t go nearly far enough.

It is disappointing, to begin with, that the government could offer only a sketchy outline of what it intends to do to right this injustice.

The government has been working on legalizing pot ever since it was elected three years ago, and the date that would come into effect had been known for months. Yet it was not ready with legislation on the much-discussed issue of pardons. All Goodale could do was promise that a bill to put this into effect will be introduced by the end of the year.

That keeps many thousands of Canadians waiting months longer to have the shadow of a cannabis conviction lifted from them. As has been well documented, that can have profoundly negative effects on their ability to get housing, obtain a job, volunteer or enter another country.

Goodale did spell out some important and positive steps last week. He said the normal application fee of $631 will be waived, and the standard waiting periods (five or 10 years, depending on the type of conviction) will be eliminated. That’s all to the good.

However, he made it clear that what the government has in mind amounts to what is known as a “record suspension.” That would not erase a past offence; rather, it would set the conviction aside and keep any record of it out of the main national police database. Anyone asked on a form whether they have been convicted of a criminal offence would still have to answer “yes.”

The government’s plan falls well short of eliminating all records of a past offence, known as expungement. That’s what many defence lawyers, advocates for those with cannabis convictions and the federal New Democrats are calling for, and there’s a strong argument for going in that direction.

By legalizing cannabis, the government is effectively conceding that nearly a century of prohibition of the drug in this country has been at best wrong-headed, and at worst a grave injustice perpetrated against hundreds of thousands of people. Yet from what we know now, its intended remedy will be a half-measure that will put the onus on those convicted to seek a pardon and still leave them vulnerable to potential negative consequences. You might be interested in One argument against going all the way to full “expungement” of past convictions is that it won’t erase records held by U.S. authorities and so those with past convictions may still find themselves prevented from crossing the border. But the Americans have already made it clear that the pardon policy won’t cut the ice with them anyway, and their policy is that it’s “business as usual” at the border.

Beyond that, the government argues that expungement should be reserved for crimes that amounted to an historical injustice. It has gone that route with Bill C66, a law passed in June that automatically expunged the records for some past offences related to same-sex relationships. For those affected, it’s as if the conviction never happened.

There’s a good argument, however, to treat cannabis convictions in much the same way. Considerable research has shown the law was applied unevenly, that Indigenous, Black and poor people were penalized much more severely because police and prosecutors chose to use the pot laws as a weapon against them. They disproportionately suffered the effects of a criminal conviction in the past and continue to live with that stigma today.

There may be technical or logistical reasons why past pot convictions can’t all be erased immediately. But in principle the government should do all it can to right this injustice as quickly as possible and as fully as possible. — Toronto Star

Ticked Off

When I watch, read or listen to news of the world, specifically Canada, but get flooded with what is going on with the U.S. There are more important things going on in the world other than what those idiotic, gun-happy Americans are doing.

Ticked Off

The price of goods will rise commensurate with minimum wages going to $15 an hour. A cruel political trick by the NDP to buy your vote with your own money.

Ticked Off

That anyone thinks that the only activity of the prison system is rehabilitation. Punishment and protection of the public should come first.

Ticked Off

Why do companies pay for flyers? I’ve gone into their stores often and they never seem to have the flyer items I want. There’s no point in wasting my time and gas money to go there. Guess I’ll have to shop online.

Ticked Off

With Glen Motz and his ads on TV. Two per hour at noon. His staff is having a hard time keeping up with the successful results of the Liberal government.

Ticked Off

The city is not making more commercial land available in the south end of the city as there is obvious demand for it.

Tickled Pink

At the insensitive soul who wants to split hairs about the terms rape and sexual assault, then dramatically uses the term “assassinate” to describe what happened to Kavanaugh.

Ticked Off

At the idiots downtown who allow the destruction of all our greenspace and the homes of our wildlife so some greedy idiots can turn it all into bike trails.

Ticked Off

The downtown sidewalks are such a sticky mess; apparently no one operating a business there can operate a broom.

Ticked Off

That people with double or triple car garages and double or triple car driveways still park on the street encroaching on their neighbours’ yards. Do they not realize that some young child could run out onto the street and be hidden from the view of an oncoming vehicle and be hit and seriously hurt.

Ticked Off

Found a black widow spider in my yard today and their bite can be poisonous. Be careful and always wear gloves as a precaution.

Tickled Pink

If you choose to smoke and become impaired on the job site It will be my choice to send you home and terminate your employment.

Tickled Pink

Wish we had Donald Trump running our country. He would bring back jobs, build pipelines and not worry about special interest groups.

Ticked Off

The golf course is the best part of Redcliff! The town needs to step up and help.

Tickled Pink

That the NDP government introduced a carbon levy (aka tax). Our family now has an updated furnace thermostat and we received a rebate for installing solar panels.