Montreal Gazette

The Constituti­on: crisis, what crisis?

-

Justin Trudeau was quite correct to reject Philippe Couillard’s constituti­onal proposal. The myth that Quebec is “out of the Constituti­on” is just that — a myth that has been carefully nurtured for decades for political and ideologica­l reasons.

The Constituti­on Act of 1982 is not, has never been and never will be “a new Constituti­on.”

This act patriated our constituti­onal documents and added a much-needed Charter of Rights, an amending formula (two, in fact) and increased provincial rights on natural resources (that one is often forgotten). The remainder of the Constituti­on Act of 1867, formerly the British North America Act, was left unchanged.

I can understand the average citizen not grasping this technicali­ty, but politician­s (many of whom are lawyers), university professors and experience­d reporters should know better than to suggest — as Louis Bernard, premier René Lévesque’s chief of staff, wrote in this newspaper a few years ago — that Quebec is constituti­onally isolated or that there is a constituti­onal crisis in Canada.

High time to bury this myth once and for all.

André Bordeleau, Kirkland letters@montrealga­zette.com

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada