Congregations rally as Catholic church plans closures
For more than 150 years, the church in Sainte- Sophie has stood in the heart of the village, its steeple like a beacon summoning the faithful through its doors.
But with so few answering the call each Sunday, the small town just east of St-Jérôme is one of many facing what once would have been unimaginable: a churchless future.
As the St-Jérôme Catholic diocese contemplates whether to dramatically slash the number of buildings it maintains, parishioners say they won’t accept the closures without a fight.
While the committee studying the issue won’t confirm how many churches could be closed, La Presse and a local newspaper have reported as many as 33 of the diocese’s 54 churches could be on the chopping block as of this summer.
The diocese says an announcement will be made in June.
The news isn’t sitting well with some residents in Sainte-Sophie, who have formed a group to try to save the church.
Thus far, their activities consist of trying to raise attendance at Sunday mass, and trying to show church authorities the community is willing to work to find solutions.
But Stephan Filion, the group’s founder, wonders whether the diocesan committee is even considering other options.
“The best we can do is to show we’re here, but will we be asked, questioned on the next steps?” he said. “For now it doesn’t seem to be the case. But what’s sure is that if we each stay on our own side and do nothing, nobody will ask.”
While the church doesn’t want to close buildings, dwindling attendance and soaring maintenance leave them with few options, according to the diocese’s vicar general.
“There are parishes that are technically bankrupt,” Martin Tremblay said.
“There are parishes that don’t have enough money to continue.
“We can’t continue to close our eyes to the problem.”
Tremblay said heating costs alone average between $20,000 and $40,000 per year for each church — and that doesn’t count insurance, maintenance or major renovations, which can rise into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
He said the church may be better off concentrating more of its funds on salaries and activities that directly support its mission of spreading the word of God.
“We are not managers of old buildings,” he said.
But even congregations that don’t have to contend with church maintenance say they have reason to worry.
A spokesman for the St-François-Xavier church says he learned “through the back door” that the congregation is on the list of those slated to close — even though the church was sold to the town of Prévost.
Robert Lévesque, head of the local ecclesiastical corporation that manages the parish, is rallying the community, hosting meetings with local stakeholders and adjoining parishes.
He hopes citizens can convince church authorities to allow his church to keep operating and maybe even expand with a project to reach out to local youth.
Even if the commission recommends closing in June, he won’t give up.
“I’ll continue to fight for another round for sure, to recover, to assert my ideas,” Lévesque said.
“It’s not because they decide today to close us that we can’t have another meeting or come up with a new strategy to prove to them it wasn’t a good decision, and to let us reopen.”
The St-Jérôme diocese is not the only one being forced to make difficult decisions.
The Quebec organization that tracks religious heritage says some 500 places of worship — representing 18 per cent of the total — have been sold, closed or re-purposed since 2003.
Since 2011, about 40 have closed every year, according to the Conseil du patrimoine religieux du Québec.
Alain Faubert, an auxiliary bishop with the Archdiocese in Montreal, says about 60 churches have been closed or sold in the city in the last 20 to 30 years — including several sold to other Christian groups.
He says authorities in Montreal always explore all possible options before closing a church, such as sharing the space with community organizations.
“A church is more than just a place of worship,” he said. “It’s a type of centre for life and service, of dignity and solidarity at the heart of a neighbourhood.”
Montreal churches have hosted refugees, daycares, Alcoholics Anonymous meetings, food banks and drop-in centres for the homeless, Faubert says.
But in more rural areas, he says there may be fewer options.
As closures loom, communities such as Sainte-Sophie are also wondering what will happen to the village cemetery, and whether their downtowns will be anchored by condo buildings or pharmacies.
Filion also worries about elderly parishioners, who he believes will stop attending mass rather than travel to other towns.
Tremblay, on the other hand, believes the faithful will adjust.
“The Catholic Church, at its historic origins, didn’t have churches, and it worked,” he said. “So we don’t need churches to do our work. We just need a place to gather.”