National Post

Rural area access still unsettled, says auditor

Base standard for all of Canada could cost $6.5B

- David Paddon

The federal government hasn’t establishe­d a clear strategy that sets out the costs and timelines for bringing broadband access in rural and remote areas up to the national minimum standard, Canada’s auditor general said Tuesday in his fall report to Parliament.

The AG’s report says officials in the Department of Innovation, Science and Economic Developmen­t estimated it might cost $6.5 billion or more to provide all parts of Canada with at least the minimum standard.

In its response, ISED said it agreed with the report and began a consultati­on in June to establish a national digital and data strategy that includes broadband connectivi­ty.

That was followed by a meeting of federal, provincial and territoria­l ministers who issued an Oct. 26 statement that included support for universal access to internet speeds of at least 50 megabits per second download and 10 MBps upload.

ISED minister Navdeep Bains told a media briefing in Ottawa after the report was issued that he and his counterpar­ts had agreed “to develop a long-term strategy to improve access to high-speed internet connectivi­ty and services to all Canadians.”

The auditor’s report also says, among other things, that the lack of a national strategy had hampered the implementa­tion of the Liberal government’s Connect to Innovate program, which allocated $500 million over five years starting in 2016.

It says ISED has been slow to inform stakeholde­rs about when backbone network infrastruc­ture funded by the program will be available to them and what they would be charged for access.

“However, this informatio­n cannot be released until after the contracts have been signed. We found that the department encountere­d delays in completing the due diligence work required ahead of signing.

“It began due diligence work on each project only after the minister provided conditiona­l approval.”

The report adds that only three contracts had been signed under the program as of June 2018.

In his address to media, Bains said there have been 180 projects approved to date for more than 900 rural and remote communitie­s — exceeding the original goal of 300 communitie­s when the program was announced.

“We’re also laying the groundwork for 5G deployment (fifth-generation wireless networks), including in rural areas, and making more spectrum available in ... upcoming auctions.”

The auditor general suggested that ISED review the way it manages the spectrum auctions.

It said there was concern that there will be less spectrum available for fixed wireless broadband in rural and remote areas if some of it is redeployed for mobile access after an auction of 3,500 megahertz spectrum planned for 2020.

It also said the deployment conditions don’t provide a strong enough incentive for licence holders to offer services outside major urban centres or to sublicence unused spectrum to smaller service providers in rural and remote areas.

In its response to the auditor, ISED said it will continue to address the needs of rural and remote communitie­s when developing licensing rules, study ways to make unused spectrum available to underserve­d areas and to use a variety of licensing methods including non-competitiv­e licensing processes in addition to auctions.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada