Independent senators seeking investigation of Beyak’s ethics

Five want to know if Senate rules violated

OTTAWA • The saga of Sen. Lynn Beyak’s letters continues, with some of her Senate colleagues seeking to determine if she has violated ethics and spending rules.

Five members of the independent senators group have written to Senate ethics officer Pierre Legault asking him to investigate whether letters they say are commonly believed to be racist violate the upper chamber’s rules against promoting hatred. They also want the Senate’s administrative arm to decide if hosting the letters on a Senate website is a misuse of parliamentary resources.

The letters are from people who support Beyak’s comments that not enough has been made of the positives that came out of residential schools, and that Indigenous people should give up their status cards and practise their culture on their own dime.

Beyak was kicked out of the Conservative party caucus last week after she refused to remove several of letters, which party leader Andrew Scheer said included racist content.

Beyak has challenged Scheer’s version of events, calling him an inexperienced leader who fell prey to political correctness.

She now sits as an independent senator.

Beyak says her statements and the letters reflect a valid viewpoint that some are trying to stifle.

Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister Carolyn Bennett and Indigenous Services Minister Jane Philpott wrote Monday to Scheer and Conservative Senate leader Larry Smith asking for their help in getting the letters removed from the website.

The five senators who signed the letter to the ethics officer, Raymonde Gagné, Frances Lankin, Ratna Omidvar, Chantal Petitclerc and André Pratte, were all appointed in 2016.

In their complaint, they say content in some of the letters is “commonly judged to be racist” and while they support Beyak’s right to free speech, that does not include the right to promote hatred.

They want Legault to determine if the letters promote hatred or racism, noting that if they do, that would be a violation of the Senate ethics code.

The investigation will be one of the first things Legault undertakes. He was appointed to the role by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau only a month ago.

Sen. Lynn Beyak