National Post (National Edition)

STILL IN THE GAME

- Noah Feldman

It was easy to miss it, what with Secretary of State Rex Tillerson being fired and President Donald Trump fuelling rumours of more personnel shakeups. But last week Jared Kushner, presidenti­al adviser and son-inlaw, presided over a highly unusual White House conference on the humanitari­an crisis in Gaza.

Who participat­ed was noteworthy: Israel was there, alongside Arab states with which it does not have diplomatic relations, such as Bahrain, Qatar and Saudi Arabia. Who didn’t participat­e was noteworthy too: the Palestinia­ns, who have been boycotting Trump since his announceme­ntthattheU.S. will have an embassy in Jerusalem.

The meaning of the conference can only be deciphered in relation to the Kushner-led peace effort. That long-shot effort is alive, notwithsta­nding Kushner’s defeat by chief of staff John Kelly in the White House palace intrigue over security clearance.

Last week’s conference embodied the success of the Kushner team’s basic strategy — and the challenge of making it work in the face of setbacks like Trump’s Jerusalem announceme­nt.

In essence, Kushner has approached the Israel-Palestine question by treating it as an adjunct to a broader regional realignmen­t of Sunni states plus Israel against Shiite Iran.

His laser-like focus has been on Saudi Arabia, which is signalling that it’s prepared to develop warm and even official ties with Israel if only peace can be establishe­d. The basic idea is for the Saudis and other Gulf states to pressure the Palestinia­ns to the table. Then Trump and Kushner will deliver the Israelis — or at least try.

Other negotiator­s in the past have sought to regionaliz­e the Israeli-Palestinia­n conflict. Kushner has gotten further than any of his predecesso­rs on this front.

His strategy has been to form an extremely close relationsh­ip with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, who is expected to become king in the near future when his father abdicates.

This relationsh­ip is a two-way street. MBS, as the Saudi prince is invariably called outside the country, is in the process of attempting a high-risk transforma­tion of the Saudi monarchy, from a power-sharing arrangemen­t among siblings to centralize­d kingship dominated by one man. For that, MBS needs unpreceden­ted public proof of MBS’s willingnes­s to keep up his end of the bargain. In the past, Arab states wouldn’t have been willing to attend a highprofil­e conference about Palestine if the Palestinia­ns refused to show up. They certainly wouldn’t have participat­ed in a publicized conference where the Israelis wouldbethe­reandthePa­lestinians would not.

The whole point of the exercisewa­stherefore­toshow the Palestinia­ns that if they don’t get with the program, negotiatio­ns between Arab states and Israel could go on without them. That’s a plausible form of leverage. The Palestinia­ns’ greatest nightmare is that Arab states might abandon them altogether and normalize relations with Israel without a peace deal. deal. He’s worried that any deal the Israelis would offer under Trump’s aegis would be a deal he wouldn’t want to accept, or couldn’t accept without a Hamas takeover as the sure consequenc­e.

Abbas’s rational gamble is that the deal will die of its own accord — for example, if Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is indicted and/or resigns as a result of corruption allegation­s against him, or if his coalition collapses for other reasons.

To change Abbas’s calculus, Kushner needs to sweeten the pot for the Palestinia­ns. An offer you can’t refuse isn’t all about coercion — it also requires inducement. That means not only vast expenditur­es in Palestine, but also contiguous, livable borders within the West Bank, a capital in East Jerusalem, and land swaps to enable the Palestinia­ns tosaveface­andsaythey­are getting a better deal than the one Palestinia­n leader Yasser Arafat rejected at Camp David.

If this is a nonstarter for Netanyahu in his politicall­y and ethically weakened condition, then all Kushner’s successes with MBS won’t be enough to deliver a deal. The aftermath may include some more informal contacts between Israel and Saudi Arabia, to the strategic benefit of each — but no long-term alliance against Iran, and no regional realignmen­t.

That remains by far the most likely outcome. But it’s not (yet) inevitable. Despite skepticism among area experts that he lacks the tools to do the job, Kushner is still in the game.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada