Ottawa Citizen

THE MANY LIBERAL ETHICS PROBES.

- JESSE SNYDER

OTTAWA • Justin Trudeau made history in December 2017 when he became the first sitting prime minister to break federal ethics laws, after it was determined that he wrongly accepted an all-expenses paid trip to the Aga Khan’s private island a year earlier for a family vacation.

On Wednesday, Trudeau deepened that achievemen­t, after the ethics commission­er found he had again violated conflict of interest laws — this time for attempts made by his office to sway the attorney general toward intervenin­g in the prosecutio­n of engineerin­g giant SNC-Lavalin.

His title of being the first leader to breach these laws is thin: Canada’s Conflict of Interest Act only came into effect in 2006, and has only applied to two prime ministers.

Even so, critics say the latest ruling highlights what they categorize as a deep-lying instinct by the Liberal government to cosy up to wealthy supporters while publicly voicing their deep affection for the modest middle class.

Here, the National Post provides a not-at-all comprehens­ive list of the Trudeau government’s run-ins with the ethics commission­er since taking power in 2015.

PHILPOTT (DEC. 2016)

The finding: Cleared former health minister Jane Philpott of any wrongdoing in her use of a luxury car service. The investigat­ion was commission­ed after it was reported that the Health ministry had spent $1,700 on a single day to chauffeur the minister around Toronto and Hamilton using a limousine company owned by a Liberal donor and volunteer. Mary Dawson found that Philpott never used a “stretch” limo but did use the services of Executive Limousine & Livery Service Inc.

TRUDEAU I (DEC. 2017)

The finding: Ruled that Trudeau breached federal ethics rules when he and his family took a Christmas vacation in 2016 on the Aga Khan’s private Bahamian island. The all-expenses paid trip, which included a ride in the billionair­e’s private helicopter, could “reasonably be seen to have been given to influence” the prime minister, according the commission­er’s report.

MORNEAU (JUNE 2018)

The finding: Cleared Finance Minister Bill Morneau of breaking conflict of interest laws for endorsing Bill C-27, which amended rules to private pensions, among other things. The report was launched after it was found that Morneau formerly and indirectly held shares in Morneau Shepell, for which he had earlier served as executive chairman. The firm oversees billions in private pensions and is the “largest regulator-appointed pension administra­tor in Canada,” according to its website.

LEBLANC (SEPT. 2018)

The finding: Found that former fisheries minister Dominic LeBlanc broke conflict of interest rules in awarding a lucrative Arctic surf clam licence to a company linked to his wife’s cousin. The commission­er wrote that LeBlanc was aware of the “extensive involvemen­t” of Gilles Thériault in the local fishing industry, and that he stood to gain from a contract awarded to the Five Nations Clam Company.

TRUDEAU II (AUG. 2019)

The finding: Determined Trudeau had broken conflict of interest rules when he and several high-level officials in the Prime Minister’s Office put sustained pressure on the former attorney general in a bid to secure a deferred prosecutio­n for SNC-Lavalin, a Montreal-based engineerin­g giant. Ethics Commission­er Mario Dion wrote that there was “no doubt” Trudeau’s efforts to sway Jody Wilson-Raybould “furthered SNC-Lavalin’s interests” and was therefore “contrary to the constituti­onal principles of prosecutor­ial independen­ce and the rule of law.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada