The Guardian (Charlottetown)

Needs in both places

It is a shame that this has become an either/or scrap over limited funds

- BY SUSAN HARTLEY Dr. Susan Hartley is a clinical psychologi­st and critic for health and wellness, Green Party of P.E.I.

The #HowManyWad­e Campaign, coupled with the recent coverage in the local media and by the University of King’s College Journalism school, is bringing the reality of mental health needs to the forefront of our conversati­ons and concerns.

Vulnerable Islanders have found the courage to publicly speak up and talk about their fears, anxieties and distress. All Islanders deserve this issue to be part of a bigger conversati­on than what is currently happening in government.

I work in the mental health system in P.E.I. I choose to work outside of the government­funded programs for many reasons and recognize the privilege I have in being able to speak out without concern of repercussi­ons. My independen­ce also allows me to be an advocate for individual­s in the system who are not receiving appropriat­e, ethical or timely care.

In this role I have had the opportunit­y to interact with many profession­als and bureaucrat­s within the publicly funded system. At times I have been impressed by the willingnes­s of bureaucrat­s, physicians, and frontline workers to go out of their way to make my clients’ situations just a bit better.

Too often, however, there has been an unwillingn­ess to collaborat­e or even engage in discussion regarding a mutual client’s needs. Most concerning is when well-intentione­d, compassion­ate and dedicated mental health workers are asked to offer interventi­on that is beyond their scope of expertise because there just isn’t anyone else; or when clients are seen on an urgent basis and there isn’t a program for comprehens­ive or follow-up care to offer them.

To be honest, this doesn’t feel like a system.

I have commented previously that Islanders are being offered Band-Aid solutions rather than co-ordinated sustainabl­e options. And it seems to me that the rhetoric of recent weeks is about how to share the only Band-Aid left in the box.

The $400,000 will not cover the needs or fill the gaps. Some within the system are advocating for expanded acute care services while others defend the decision to spend the money on preventive measures within the school system.

It is a shame that this has become an either/or scrap over limited funds when we clearly have needs in both places, and more importantl­y, distracts us from the bigger conversati­on about the overarchin­g need for an integrated system joining all the parts in a co-ordinated, seamless manner.

It is not apparent to me that the Department of Health and Wellness has applied best practices in its management of the resources allocated to mental health.

Islanders need a plan that is regularly evaluated and reviewed, and adapted as unintended consequenc­es are identified and as needs change. Without a plan, how is it determined where best to spend the next $400,000? By whoever wins the scrap?

Not good enough.

Our decision-makers must become focused on the realities at hand. Islanders are anxious and concerned and we need leaders who know how to resolve their difference­s, apply best practice management and design approaches, and provide well thought out direction.

 ?? GUARDIAN FILE PHOTO ?? Dr. Heather Keizer, Prince Edward Island’s chief mental health and addictions officer, recently slammed the province’s handling of mental health services and diverting funds.
GUARDIAN FILE PHOTO Dr. Heather Keizer, Prince Edward Island’s chief mental health and addictions officer, recently slammed the province’s handling of mental health services and diverting funds.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada