Opposition hammers proposed changes to Access to Information law
Federal cabinet ministers were on the defensive Wednesday as opposition parties hammered proposed changes to the law that gives Canadians access to government files.
The criticisms largely echoed those voiced last month by the federal information watchdog, who said the Liberals’ plan to amend the Access to Information Act would take people’s right to know backwards.
The Liberals say their proposed access legislation, introduced in June, will raise the bar on openness and transparency following years of inaction by the previous Conservative government.
That was the message Treasury Board President Scott Brison, who is responsible for overseeing the act, and Democratic Institutions Minister Karina Gould delivered to the House ethics committee Wednesday.
“As we developed these reforms, we were guided by the principle that government information belongs to the people we serve,” Brison told committee members.
“We remain committed to this principle.”
But opposition MPs zeroed in on proposals that would let an agency refuse to process an access request unless it identified the specific type of record, the subject, and time-frame.
Conservatives and New Democrats noted that Information Commissioner Suzanne Legault has called the proposed criteria unreasonable, and they expressed concern the clause would be abused.
Brison said the measure was intended to prevent “frivolous or vexatious” requests that are made in bad faith and often “gum up” the access to information system.
But he refused to say who would determine whether a request meets the criteria, and a senior Treasury Board official testified that less than one per cent of current requests are considered frivolous.