A question of response
Stone throwers face different fates across the globe
President Donald Trump’s assertion that stones thrown by Latin American protesters at American troops should be treated as “rifles” has sparked debate about the appropriate response to rock-throwing crowds particularly after Nigerian troops appeared to use his comments as justification for a deadly crackdown on demonstrators over the weekend.
From the Gaza Strip to Africa to Europe, security forces have long dealt with stone throwers, albeit in very different ways.
Israel has killed dozens of Palestinian stone-throwers over the decades, saying that rocks constituted a threat to the lives of its soldiers. In Greece, the killing of a single stone-thrower by a rogue policeman a decade ago set off weeks of riots across the country.
A 1990 UN document, “Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials,” is widely seen as setting the international standard for the use of force in policing environments, according to Omar Shakir, the Israel and Palestine director for Human Rights Watch.
It calls on law-enforcement agencies to show maximum restraint and to use firearms only in cases in which an “imminent threat of death or serious injury” is identified.
These standards have been interpreted differently around the world.
Last week, Trump called attention to a migrant caravan of several thousand Central Americans making their way toward the U.S. border. Although the caravan is still some 1,200 kilometres (800 miles) from the border, Trump has mobilized troops and declared that if U.S. soldiers face rock-throwing migrants, they should react as though the rocks were “rifles.” Trump later said he was merely calling for the arrests of stone throwers.
But following Trump’s comments, Nigeria’s military sent out a tweet that appeared to use his words as justification for shooting and killing Shiite protesters. It later removed the tweet.
Shakir said he fears Trump’s comments could encourage other forces to loosen their rules of engagement.
“Trump’s brazen, inflammatory statements, days before U.S. midterm elections, have already been seized on by rights abusers to justify more expansive open fire standards,” he said.
Here is a look at how some countries around the world respond to stone throwers.
ISRAEL/PALESTINIANS
Israeli forces have been confronting Palestinian stone throwers in the West Bank and Gaza Strip for decades. Israeli tactics have evolved over the years, particularly with the increased use of “non-lethal” crowd-dispersal tools such as tear gas and rubber bullets.
Israeli officials say that live fire is used only as a last resort, when soldiers’ lives are threatened. But critics accuse Israel of unnecessarily, and perhaps illegally, using deadly force.
In recent months, for instance, over 160 Palestinians have been killed during mass protests along Gaza’s border with Israel. Many have been unarmed.
Israel says the crowds are being incited by the Hamas militant group, and the threats go far beyond stone throwing. It says protesters are throwing grenades and firebombs and trying to infiltrate the border to attack Israeli civilians.
David Tzur, a former commander of Israel’s Border Police, a paramilitary force often used in riot-control situations, said shooting to kill is to be avoided as much as possible and that nonlethal force is sufficient in most cases. But he said troops could be justified using live fire in more chaotic situations, if a moving vehicle is pelted with stones in a tense locale, for instance.
He said he expected U.S. troops to do everything possible to avoid deadly force, since doing so escalates the situation. “My guess is they won’t be eager to start shooting,” he said.
GREECE
In Greece, firebombs and stone-throwing are routine occurrences at anarchist demonstrations held on most weekends. Police typically respond with tear gas and stun grenades to disperse the crowds.
In 2008, a rogue policeman fired his gun at a group of youths in central Athens, killing a 15-yearold protester. The death sparked two weeks of riots in major cities across Greece, and the policeman was jailed for murder.