This is the ideal pound cake recipe
It started as a simple enough task: find a really good pound cake recipe.
After all, how much variation could there be in a time-honoured recipe that combines flour, sugar, butter and eggs? A lot, as it turns out.
I started with a recipe from King Arthur Flour that hewed mostly to the traditional formula of using a pound of the four main ingredients, except halved because I wanted to stick to one loaf pan. I decided a headto-head competition was in order, so I thumbed through my cookbooks for something different and made “Elvis Presley’s favourite Pound Cake” from “Gourmet Today.” It was a big departure that used cream instead of some of the butter and cake flour (and less of it) instead of allpurpose.
Tasters were torn. They liked the flavour of Elvis, but the texture of the other King. So naturally, I had to throw a third into the mix.
This contender, similar in ratios to the Elvis cake but with sour cream instead of heavy cream, came from pastry wizard Stella Parks of Serious Eats, with whom I had consulted about why the original two were different and why the Elvis cake looked so odd and lumpy on top.
Her cake was perfect — moist and dense in the way you want a pound cake to be: golden, domed — but a few folks could not get behind the distinctive sour cream flavour (which I loved). So ... I created a mash-up.
As it always is, Parks’s advice was invaluable. She encouraged me to look at the ratios of the ingredients compared to each other, which I was able to use to my advantage when I started tweaking the amounts of flour, sugar and butter to bring the flavour of the Elvis cake in line with the textures of hers and King Arthur’s.
The most crucial tip, however, was how technique matters as much as ingredients. Just from looking at my photo of the Elvis cake, she diagnosed exactly what had gone wrong: the temperature of the ingredients was off (butter and eggs too warm), the bowl was not scraped enough during mixing and the wet and dry ingredients were not added gradually enough. All of those things can cause the emulsion of the cake batter — yes, just like a mayo, where ingredients are supposed to be held in an even suspension — to break. This recipe combats all those problems.
Cool room temperature is a good benchmark to aim for when it comes to ingredients. An instant-read thermometer is really helpful here (cut to the video of me probing a stick of butter, repeatedly) but if you don’t have one, we have provided other cues and tips to get you to the right place. And, yes, temperature also plays into how long you are supposed to wait before eating the cake — letting it cool slowly and completely helps lock in the moisture for the best texture. But I’m not going to tattle if you aren’t that patient.
To be honest, the many pounds of ingredients I went through (and the ones I may have gained sampling the various iterations) should be illegal. But in the end, it was worth it for a loaf that is tender yet firm, moist and bright yellow on the inside with a downright addictive crackly sugar crust — one of my tasters’ favourite features — on top. I would settle for nothing less, and now you won’t have to either.
Ideal Pound Cake
Makes 12 servings (one 9-inch loaf)
10 tablespoons (1 stick plus 2 tbsp unsalted butter equals 5 ounces or 140 grams), at cool room temperature (firm but a finger will leave a dent), plus more for the pan
1 cups plus 2 tbsp all-purpose flour, preferably low-protein (8 ounces or 225 g), plus more for the pan
1 cups plus 2 tbsp sugar (11 ounces or 310 g)
1 teaspoon baking powder
tsp kosher salt
3 large eggs, at cool room temperature (place in hot tap water for 3 minutes) 2 tsp vanilla extract cup heavy cream (5 ounces or 140 g)
Position an oven rack in the lower third of the oven; preheat to 350 F. Lightly grease a 9-by-5-inch loaf pan with butter and dust with flour.
Combine the sugar, butter, baking powder and salt in the bowl of a stand mixer or hand-held electric mixer; beat on low speed to combine, then increase to medium. Beat until fluffy and light, about five minutes, stopping to scrape down the bowl and paddle attachment or beaters halfway through.
With the mixer still running, add the eggs one at a time, letting each fully incorporate before adding the next. Reduce the speed to low and sprinkle in 1/3 of the flour, then add the vanilla extract and 1/3 of the heavy cream. Repeat with remaining flour and heavy cream, working in thirds as before.
Scrape down the bowl and paddle or beaters with a flexible spatula and resume mixing on medium speed for a second or two to ensure everything is well combined. The batter should look creamy and thick.
Transfer the batter into the pan and bake until the crust is golden (although the interior of the split crown will be quite pale), about 65 minutes, or until a toothpick or cake tester inserted toward the middle of the cake to one side of the crack in the crown comes out clean.
Cool the cake for three to four hours, then loosen with a round-edged knife and remove from the pan. To minimize moisture loss, wrap the cake tightly in plastic and continue cooling until no trace of warmth remains, which can take an additional hour or two. Slice and serve.
Adapted from recipes from King Arthur Flour, “Gourmet Today: More Than 1000 All-new Recipes for the Contemporary Kitchen” (Rux Martin/Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2009) and pastry chef and cookbook author Stella Parks.
Per serving: 320 calories; 10 grams saturated fat; 90 milligrams cholesterol; 70 mg sodium; 41 g carbohydrates; 26 g sugar; 4 g protein.