DNA testing reveals family secret
ASK AMY About a year ago, I used one of those genetic testing services. The website shows other users who share genetics with you, and allows everyone to contact each other.
Recently, I got a message from another user (a woman in her 60s in another state), that showed we were a very close genetic match.
She emailed me, saying she was looking for information on her father, whom she had never met. She said her mother had a very brief relationship with a U.S. marine during the Korean War. It turned out he had probably used a fake name. They had no photos, and they were never able to track him down. Her mother later moved to the U.S.
The woman, “Janet,” asked if it was possible if my grandfather (who is now dead) was her father. She knew very little except for what her mother (also now dead) had told her, including specific identifying physical characteristics. My grandfather was a Korean War veteran and had the exact characteristics she described (including a distinctive tattoo).
My grandfather would’ve been married to my grandmother (who is still alive) when “Janet” was been conceived. An uncle of mine was born a year before Janet.
I always saw my grandfather as a good, caring family man. I have not told anyone about this. I do not want to tarnish his memory, upset my grandmother, or change how my family views him, when he’s not around to defend himself.
Janet would like to meet my aunts and uncles, but I have told her I am not comfortable giving her their contact information. She has recently started pleading with me, and I truly feel awful for not giving it to her. What do I do here? — TORN
One (perhaps unforeseen) aspect of using genetic testing is the way the results can open up confounding human dilemmas concerning long-buried family secrets. Recently, I was at a gathering where several people had used a genetic matching site — and all of them noted shocking, unanticipated results, including being matched with (half ) siblings they hadn’t known about. And yet all reported that this ultimately was a positive experience.
In your case, “Janet” has already received useful genetic information. She now (quite understandably) wants more. You should at least answer any questions you’re able to answer.
If you aren’t willing to even ask your aunts and uncles if they would be open to contact with her, then she will have to find another conduit to them.
It would be best if your family was open to the idea that people are complicated, and don’t always do the right thing — but this is the fullness of the human experience, and ultimately this is something to explore and embrace, rather than deny.