‘Racist’ doc sends up ‘red flag’ over RCMP

The Peterborough Examiner - - NATIONAL NEWS - MIKE BLANCHFIELD

OTTAWA — The emer­gence of an RCMP ques­tion­naire tar­get­ing Mus­lim asy­lum seek­ers in Quebec prompted fresh ac­cu­sa­tions Thurs­day that the Lib­eral govern­ment mis­man­aged this past sum­mer’s mas­sive flow of mi­grants from the U.S.

The ques­tion­naire was used at the Quebec border cross­ing that saw an in­flux of thou­sands of asy­lum seek­ers from the U.S., many of them of Haitian de­scent who were con­cerned about the Trump ad­min­is­tra­tion’s de­ci­sion to can­cel a pro­gram that al­lowed them to stay in the coun­try.

Among other things, the ques­tion­naire asked opin­ions about re­li­gious prac­tice, head cov­er­ings as­so­ci­ated with Mus­lim women and ter­ror­ist groups with mainly Mus­lim mem­bers.

Toronto im­mi­gra­tion lawyer Clifford McCarten said he ob­tained a copy of the doc­u­ment from a client seek­ing refugee sta­tus, who had been given the three-page, 41-ques­tion doc­u­ment by mis­take.

“He was shocked by the ques­tions,” said McCarten, who pro­vided a copy to The Cana­dian Press.

The man was orig­i­nally from a Mus­lim coun­try, he added.

“Canada is a very lib­eral coun­try that be­lieves in free­dom of re­li­gious prac­tice and equal­ity between men and women. What is your opin­ion of this sub­ject? How would you feel if your boss was a wo­man? How do you feel about women who do not wear the hi­jab?” says the ques­tion­naire, which also asked the same ques­tion about other head and body cov­er­ings, in­clud­ing the du­patta, niqab, chador and burka.

A spokesman for Pub­lic Safety Min­is­ter Ralph Goodale said the govern­ment found out on Tues­day about the ex­is­tence of the ques­tion­naire from a “stake­holder” who takes an in­ter­est in the work of the depart­ment.

Pub­lic Safety spokesman Scott Bard­s­ley said the depart­ment was im­me­di­ately con­cerned and the doc­u­ment is no longer be­ing used by the RCMP.

“Some of the ques­tions were in­ap­pro­pri­ate and in­con­sis­tent with govern­ment pol­icy,” Bard­s­ley said in an e-mailed state­ment.

Bard­s­ley said the doc­u­ment was only used “lo­cally,” but would not say whether there would be reper­cus­sions for any of the Moun­ties in­volved in its cre­ation.

He re­ferred those ques­tions to the RCMP, but a spokes­woman said Thurs­day the Moun­ties would not be grant­ing in­ter­views on the topic. In a writ­ten state­ment, the RCMP said the “in­ter­view guide” was used by its Quebec C Di­vi­sion and “has been re­vised to bet­ter eval­u­ate in­di­vid­u­als com­ing into the coun­try whose ori­gin is un­known, while be­ing re­spect­ful of their sit­u­a­tions.”

McCarten said the ex­is­tence of the doc­u­ment raises ques­tions about the fed­eral govern­ment’s com­pe­tence in man­ag­ing the sud­den surge of arrivals from the U.S.

“If, in fact, this was a lo­cal de­tach­ment mak­ing this de­ci­sion — which I find a bit hard to be­lieve — then it’s deeply con­cern­ing that one of the most, if not the most prob­lem­atic cri­sis spot in Cana­dian im­mi­gra­tion and refugee pol­icy right now ... doesn’t have a fed­eral strat­egy for how screen­ing is hap­pen­ing.”

Matthew Dube, the NDP pub­lic safety critic, said in an in­ter­view the ques­tion­naire raises “red flags” about whether the RCMP is en­gaged in wide­spread racial pro­fil­ing, and he called on Goodale to launch a broad in­quiry to find out.

He said he has se­ri­ous con­cerns that Goodale didn’t know about the ques­tion­naire un­til Tues­day.

“I have no idea how such a racist, pro­fil­ing ques­tion­naire could ever be part of an op­er­a­tional pro­ce­dure.”

Jenny Kwan, the NDP im­mi­gra­tion critic, said the govern­ment needs to pro­vide more an­swers on how the ques­tion­naire was used.

“The num­ber of times some­one prays should have no bear­ing on their refugee sta­tus. That is not who we are,” she said.

Other ques­tions asked the ap­pli­cants to spec­ify their re­li­gion and “how of­ten” they prac­tise their re­li­gion.

McCarten said the RCMP needs to con­duct se­cu­rity screen­ing, but the ques­tions be­ing asked don’t cover all po­ten­tial threats to Canada.

“It ap­pears to in­struct RCMP of­fi­cers to be ask­ing ques­tions to the ex­clu­sion of other types of con­cerns, specif­i­cally the right-wing, white su­prem­a­cist vi­o­lence hap­pen­ing in the U.S. and that we have a his­tory of in Canada,” he said.

“It asks ques­tions that are dis­crim­i­na­tory, that re­flect a kind of in­sti­tu­tional bias and an in­sti­tu­tional ig­no­rance of the RCMP of the na­ture of risk.”

He said ask­ing a Mus­lim their opin­ion of head cov­er­ings is “ab­surd” and akin to “ask­ing a Jewish per­son what their opin­ions are about men who don’t wear the yarmulke.”


An RCMP of­fi­cer stand­ing in Saint-Bernard-de-La­colle, Que., on Aug. 7, ad­vises mi­grants that they are about to il­le­gally cross from Cham­plain, N.Y., and will be ar­rested. A spokesman for Pub­lic Safety Min­is­ter Ralph Goodale says an RCMP ques­tion­naire...

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada

© PressReader. All rights reserved.