Book Club shimmers like 50 shades of chardonnay
In Book Club, Jane Fonda, Diane Keaton, Candice Bergen and Mary Steenburgen play four best friends who have not only been in the same reading circle for 40 years, but have also achieved almost identical consumerist heights.
Drinking white wine and arranging (but never actually consuming) bespoke appetizers against the backdrops of their immaculate Los Angeles kitchens, the lives of these characters might differ in the details, but not their prosperous, physically fit, almost freakishly well-preserved gestalt.
Fonda plays Vivian, a wealthy hotel owner who prefers casual sex to commitment; Keaton plays Diane, whose husband died a year ago and whose kids are nagging her to move to Arizona, presumably to dry up and quietly senesce; Bergen’s Sharon is a divorced federal judge who gave up romance years ago; and Steenburgen plays Carol, a cheerful homemaker who longs to spice things up with her longtime husband, Bruce (Craig T. Nelson).
As Book Club opens, the group has just finished Cheryl Strayed’s Wild. (The underwhelmed verdict: “She hiked. She lost her boot. She did heroin.”) Then someone suggests they tackle Fifty Shades of Grey, the DIY piece of Twilight fan fiction that became a cultural phenomenon. Soon, the women are devouring E.L. James’s violet prose and polite violence with varying degrees of alarm and avidity, with each of them experiencing an erotic awakening no less revelatory for being achieved without actual handcuffs and a whip.
Book Club, which was directed by Bill Holderman from a script he wrote with Erin Simms, has been called Sex and the City of a Certain Age, although this city is notional in its realism (welcome to an L.A. where no people of colour live, work or even qualify as background players), and the libidinous activity is strictly PG-13: at one point, an errant f-word is ingeniously camouflaged with a discreet cough. The script is a-bubble with witty, on-point observations about aging bodies and flagging sex drives (at one point, Carol compares a part of her anatomy to Werner Herzog’s Cave of Forgotten Dreams), which enliven otherwise generic setups and sluggish, off-kilter pacing. Stodginess, an inherent hazard of the genre, is kept reasonably at bay with the help of choice cuts from Tom Petty, Paul Simon and Bob Dylan.
The all-star ensemble, dominated by actresses who were at their height in the 1970s, works well as an easygoing team, their mutual warmth enhanced by the kind of diffuse, soft-edged light made famous by the director Nancy Meyers.
As an example of fan-fic-fic, Book Club bears next to no resemblance to the steamy literature to which it pays mostly tepid homage. But it has brio, rueful humour and celebratory verve that is impossible to resist.
— Three stars