They shoulda been contenders
And the award nominees who got overlooked are ...
NEW YORK — Awards season tends to winnow a field of films and performances until many of the same names are read week after week, award show after award show, leading up to the Academy Awards for which nominees will be announced today. This process always leaves deserving nominees left out for lack of buzz, awareness or box office, especially given what was an awfully good year for movies.
Much love has been heaped on the likes of A Star Is Born, Roma, Green Book and The Favourite. There have been occasional attempts to upend the march to the Oscars, or at least pause for reconsideration.
The Los Angeles Film Critics Association, in a muchpraised selection, picked Debra Granick (Leave No Trace), for best director when few had her (or, notably, any other woman) in the mix. The National Society of Film Critics went back to an acclaimed if little-seen April release, Chloe Zhao’s The Rider, for its best picture winner.
The movies of 2018 were simply too good and too many to be filed neatly into a steady drumbeat of favourites. Here are just a few of the performers, filmmakers and films who warrant Oscar (but may not get) recognition as much as any other nominee:
BEST ACTRESS
Kathryn Hahn,: Private Life Amandla Stenberg,: The Hate U Give
Joanna Kulig,:Cold War Regina Hall,:
Support the Girls Toni Collette,: Hereditary
It is easily, overwhelmingly, the most crowded category of the year, and this bunch still leaves out unforgettable performances by Elsie Fisher (Eighth Grade), Carey Mulligan (Wildlife), Jamie Lee Curtis (Halloween), and Juliette Binoche (Let the Sunshine In). Yet these five all seem to
be on the outside of the Lady Gaga/Olivia Colman/Glenn Close favourites despite work that was at turns staggeringly ravishing (Kulig), deeply personal and poised (Stenberg, in a star-making performance), insanely committed (Collette), comically but forcefully poignant (Hall), and flat-out human (Hahn).
BEST ACTOR
Lakeith Stanfield,: Sorry to Bother You Joaquin Phoenix,:You Were Never Really Here John C. Reilly,: Stan & Ollie Brady Jandreau,: The Rider
Lucas Hedges,:
Ben Is Back
The most subtle and sweet performances by leading men came in more adventurous, less show-stopping roles than the likes of Rami Malek’s Freddie Mercury and Bradley Cooper’s Jackson Maine. Stanfield is the unflappable centre to the wild surrealism of Sorry to Bother You. Phoenix, twitchy and haunted, cuts like a knife through Lynne Ramsay’s deconstructed revenge thriller. Reilly, a standout also in The Sisters Brothers, gives a wonderfully sensitive performance as Oliver Hardy in Stan & Ollie. Jandreau, a Lakota cowboy, doesn’t get his due for his
magnetic performance in The Rider since much of it was based on his life. But that takes nothing away from its honesty. And few actors were more exciting and indispensable in 2018 than the quickly maturing Hedges, who has had many strong performances including his recovering addict in Ben Is Back.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Jun Jong-seo,:Burning Sissy Spacek,: The Old Man & the Gun Zoe Kazan,: The Ballad of Buster Scruggs Elizabeth Debicki,:
Widows Natalie Portman,:Vox Lux
The only thing standing in the way of a litany of awards for Jun Jong-seo’s aching, sorrowful performance in Chang-dong Lee’s masterly psychological thriller Burning is celebrity (it’s her first film), and language (since foreign films rarely get much recognition in acting categories). The Old Man & the Gun might be remembered for Robert Redford’s final performance, but it’s when he’s on screen with the ever-glowing Spacek that the movie lights up.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Brian Tyree Henry,: If Beale Street Could Talk Hugh Grant,: Paddington 2 Michael B. Jordan,: Black Panther
Russell Hornsby,: The Hate U Give Josh Hamilton,: Eighth Grade
Henry only has a few scenes in If Beale Street Could Talk, but they were among the most beautiful and tender of the year. (Michael Shannon had about the same screen time in 2008’s Revolutionary Road and still earned a deserved Oscar nomination.) As a desperately down-on-his-luck actor in Paddington 2, Hugh Grant gave the most delightful performance of the year (though his co-star Brendan Gleeson, as a prison chef, was close). And it’s impossible to separate the greatness of Ryan Coogler’s Black Panther from the tormented performance of Michael B. Jordan. He’s the movie’s anguished heart.
BEST DIRECTOR
Chloe Zhao,: The Rider
Joel and Ethan Coen,:The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
Frederick Wiseman,:
Monrovia, Indiana
Lucrecia Martel,: Zama Pawel Pawlikowski,:
Cold War
None of these films could have been made — or even attempted — by anyone else: the soulful melancholy of Zhao’s vividly naturalistic The Rider; the delirious splendour of Lucrecia Martel’s hypnotic adaptation; the Coen brothers’ audacious anthology of six Western morality tales; Wiseman’s sharp and patient portrait of small-town America; and Pawlikowski’s gorgeous, devastatingly concise ill-fated romance.
BEST PICTURE
The Death of Stalin First Reformed Burning Spider-Man: Into the
Spider Verse Private Life
These are many others, too, that deserve to be remembered. Everyone could, and should, have their own picks.