Charting a return to TV comedy
New series ‘Space Force’ a window into Carell as an actor and creator
As an actor, Steve Carell has shown remarkable elasticity.
He can be an outright dope, like the barely articulate Brick Tamland of “Anchorman,” or a lovable, misapprehended loser, like Michael Scott, his breakthrough role on “The Office.” Occasionally, he has been a sheer terror, like John E. du Pont, the murderous scion he played in “Foxcatcher.” They are characters that don’t share much more than the actor behind them, and reveal almost nothing about him.
So the choices Carell made when he was helping to design his lead character in “Space Force,” his new Netflix comedy series, would seem to be telling. Given the opportunity to build a role from the ground up, he cast himself as the fictional Gen. Mark Naird, a tightly wound, but highly capable, military leader charged with creating a new branch of the U.S. armed forces.
For all his time as a film and TV star, Carell, 57, remains a bit of an enigma. Almost anyone who knows him will tell you that he’s a nice guy — dedicated husband and father; generous, friendly collaborator.
But it turns out he does sometimes get the slightest bit disgruntled, at least with himself. Listen closely and you may hear it, in the course of a conversation about the making of “Space Force,” when you ask him how he decided who he wanted Naird to be.
“I wanted to find a certain humanity,” Carell said, his gentle tone giving way to strident selfflagellation as he heard his own words. “God, it is so overused to say things like that when you’re talking about comedy. Ugh, shut up. ‘Rooted in humanity.’ Give me a break.” It was only a phone interview, but you could practically hear him rolling his eyes.
Then a calm returned to his voice as he assured himself: “But I think things resonate more if there’s an underlying earnestness to them,” he said.
“Space Force,” which Netflix will release May 29, is highly anticipated: it is a series that Carell created with Greg Daniels, the showrunner of “The Office,” and it features Carell in his first ongoing TV comedy role since he left that NBC series in 2011.
But “Space Force” might not be the show viewers expect. It’s not a mockumentary and, despite its real-life inspiration, it’s not really a political satire. Carell, whose father fought in the Second World War and served afterward in the army, wants the show to have respect for the military and to find its humour in the competing demands of its protagonist’s home life and workplace.
It is a show that Carell knows will nonetheless be viewed through the lens of his previous sitcom. “We didn’t want to make the space version of ‘The Office,’” he said with a chuckle, “which is funny, because as soon as it was announced, that’s what everybody started calling it. But that was a conscious decision. We didn’t want to retrace our steps in any way.”
“Space Force” is also a window into Carell as a performer and creator — one who sees his successes somewhat differently than viewers do, who finds contentment in blank slates and who seems comfortable remaining elusive to his audience as long as his choices make sense to him.
He just doesn’t find it easy to talk about himself or to talk about why he can’t quite talk about himself. “It’s so weird to break down a show like this and talk about the components and preparation,” he said. “That doesn’t really matter to anybody except the actor. I just hope it plays.”
Though Carell might not want to acknowledge it, he possesses some industry clout. Almost a decade after his exit from the Scranton branch of the Dunder Mifflin Paper Co., Carell, an Academy Award nominee for his turn in “Foxcatcher” (2014), had been on a run of starkly dramatic and darkly comic roles: a father grappling with a son in the throes of drug addiction in “Beautiful Boy”; a disgraced television host on “The Morning Show”; Donald Rumsfeld in the Dick Cheney biopic “Vice.”
As he planned his next round of work, Carell said, “I just wanted to do something funny and silly and lighthearted. A straight-ahead comedy.”
Netflix, meanwhile, had seen “The Office” become a pillar of its TV library — its deal to stream the show ends after this year — and was eager to enlist Carell in a new comedy series. About two years ago, Netflix programming executives approached him with little more than a premise — a fictional take on the real-life efforts to establish an interstellar military wing — but it was enough to spark his interest. “We just went out on a whim,” he said.
To build this new show, Carell wanted to re-team with Daniels, a creator of “King of the Hill” and “Parks and Recreation,” who had successfully adapted the British cringe comedy “The Office” into its kinder, more heartfelt U.S. incarnation.
Daniels (who also created the new Amazon comedy “Upload”) said that he and Carell had been seeking a new project to work on together. He recalled his old “Office” leading man as an indefatigable problem solver who was ready with compromises when, say, Chili’s balked at an episode that had Pam, the receptionist played by Jenna Fischer, getting drunk in one of its restaurants. (Daniels said Carell supplied the fix in which a Chili’s manager revealed that Pam was pilfering drinks from other customers and banned her from the chain.)
Daniels also watched Carell become a bankable movie star, starting with “The 40-Year-old Virgin,” which opened the summer after “The Office” debuted on NBC. Daniels commended him for fulfilling his commitments to “The Office” even as his fame grew, noting that Carell continued to be the sort of actor who remained on a shoot until 3 a.m. to do his own driving when the task could have been handled by a stunt performer.
“If it were me,” Daniels explained, “I probably would have said, ‘I love the show — but I could do twice as many movies if I wasn’t on the show.’”
The endurance of “The Office” also means that Carell and Daniels will get asked about it when they talk publicly about “Space Force,” and they expect this. Naird, they said, is neither a floundering clone of Michael nor Carell’s attempt to escape his association with his bestknown character.
“Michael Scott is not a millstone around his neck,” Daniels said. “He’s a point of pride.”
As Daniels explained: “Michael Scott was a very mediocre leader who would do anything that anybody else suggested. All he cared about was being liked by other people.” Naird, by contrast, he said, “is a guy who’s had a lot of success, has a family, is a great leader and is very inflexible.” Rather than try to tie together the strands of the many different characters he has played, Carell pointed to his admiration for actors like Peter Sellers, the chameleonic star of films like “Being There” and “The Pink Panther.” “He could play the broadest character while at the same time being completely human and relatable,” Carell said.
The spirits of “Dr. Strangelove” and military comedies like “M*A*S*H” and “Catch-22” are also palpable in “Space Force,” which Carell and Daniels have populated with a wide variety of bureaucratic foils for Naird, including an inscrutable chief scientist (John Malkovich) and a bullying military rival (Noah Emmerich), as well as a wife (Lisa Kudrow) and daughter (Diana Silvers) who complicate his life at home.
The cast also features Fred Willard, the comic actor who died May 15, in a recurring role as Naird’s father. In a tweet, Carell said that Willard “was the funniest person that I’ve ever worked with.”
Malkovich, a two-time Oscar nominee making a rare foray into comedy, said that he could see Carell quietly striving to meet his own personal standards of perfection in their scenes together.
“He wants to get it really right,” Malkovich said. “I always had the feeling he maybe hears something and/or feels something, some secret tone or a hieroglyphic that he’s trying to get. I think he knows when he gets it, and I think he knows when he’s not quite getting what he wants. I don’t think it’s something, necessarily, that I or anybody else would know.”
Even if he could not fully comprehend Carell’s exacting approach to his work, “it’s good to be relentless in pursuit of something,” Malkovich said. “It’s good to keep after it.”