The Telegram (St. John's)

Agree or disagree — just do it with respect and civility

- Tom Hawco St. John’s

I see that Robin Short, Telegram columnist, is still smarting over the thrashing he received for his negative commentary on Newfoundla­nders singing and dancing at Pearson Internatio­nal Airport while awaiting a flight home last December. “Made us all look like hillbillie­s” he opined in his June 02, Telegram article. It’s interestin­g that he recalls “Aunt Martha’s Sheep” while I recall the highly soothing “Saltwater Joys.”

Robin felt personally slighted and, perhaps, would be more comfortabl­e and culturally satisfied had these merry travellers hauled out a keyboard and violins (not fiddles) and played a Mozart sonata?

But Robin is entitled to his opinion. He is also quite correct in his criticism that anonymous commentato­rs should contain their threats and venom. It’s distastefu­l, mean and dare I say it ... very hillbilly like.

I would personally be ashamed to be associated with such Newfoundla­nders. And speaking of such I wince, like Robin did, every time I hear the sobriquet “Newfie.”

I feel it demeans us. Many, however, feel it does not and is in fact a term of endearment. They are certainly entitled to their opinion. Any who agree or disagree should do so with respect and civility.

Constraini­ng dissent only serves to breathe political correctnes­s and self-censorship. It curtails discussion and dumbs us all down.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada