Monitoring could decrease water advisories
Guelph professor hopes method is empowering
A study by Ontario researchers suggests real-time monitoring technology at water treatment plants on reserves could significantly reduce the number of drinking-water advisories issued for First Nations across the country.
Edward McBean, an engineering professor at the University of Guelph and his former student, Kerry Black, explored the potential benefit of the systems, which use sensors to track characteristics like flow rates and chlorine levels, in an effort to help reduce the number of precautionary boil-water advisories that can linger on reserves for weeks.
After analyzing such advisories and interviewing those who work on water treatment plants in several communities, the researchers suggest the number of advisories could be reduced by more than 36 per cent if real-time monitoring was implemented.
“I believe real-time monitoring is part of the solution to the water advisories on First Nations,” McBean told The Canadian Press in an interview. “This method can empower communities to regain control of their water systems.
The research was published recently in the Journal of Water Supply: Research and Technology — AQUA.
McBean said he was inspired to look into the area after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau pledged in 2016 to eliminate boil-water advisories in Indigenous communities — a goal McBean thinks is nearly impossible.
“Exactly how he’s going to try do that, I don’t know,” McBean said.
McBean decided to focus on developing a process to tackle precautionary drinking-water advisories. The idea, he said, is to reduce the number of such advisories that are not related to inadequate water quality.
“Across all Canadian communities, 78 per cent of boil-water advisories were issued on a precautionary basis due to problems with drinking water equipment or processes,” the study says.
Those problems, McBean said, often do not mean a change in water quality, but a boil-water advisory will nonetheless remain in effect until conditions return to normal. And water testing, especially for remote communities, takes a long time with samples being shipped off to laboratories hundreds of kilometres away, he said.
Real-time monitoring systems, McBean suggests, can deal with the matter.
There are sensors that monitor attributes that include water temperature, pH levels and water turbidity — with alerts that can be sent in real-time to an operator who can then act swiftly on that information.
“Reliance upon real-time monitoring is an option for early identification of problems that can help to reduce both the frequency and duration of drinking-water advisories, and alert operators to problems about which they might not have been aware,” said the research paper.
The study notes that some reserves have implemented realtime monitoring pilot projects. The federal government invested in such a project in 57 First Nations in Alberta in 2012, and several Ontario First Nations that were on boil-water advisories for about 1,000 days over the past 10 years have benefited from a realtime water monitoring system implemented in 2013, the paper said.
McBean acknowledged, however, that real-time monitoring is not a panacea. Water treatment plant employees interviewed for the study said they appreciated the new technology, but many operators interviewed expressed concern about the security of the data and a general distrust of a third party “big brother” watching over the communities.
One community member, according to the paper, noted: “I would be concerned about who has access to this information, how it might be used and whether it would be used against (the community).”
Real-time monitoring also requires training, which some are averse to, the paper said. And if the quality of the water going into the system is inadequate or the infrastructure is poor, realtime monitoring is irrelevant until those problems are first solved, McBean said.
McBean acknowledged that his suggestion of real-time monitoring was one part of the solution, but noted that eliminating boilwater advisories is essential, whether it’s by 2021 as Trudeau has promised, or at a later date.
“You cannot live without water. That’s obvious, but it’s important to remember for those of us who have good drinking water,” McBean said. “We’ve got to do it. The question is how can we do it? I hope this method is a start.”