Claims history affects insurance cost
Dear Tony: Our Langley condo renewed our insurance policy in April and the maximum amount of coverage we can obtain is 70 per cent of our replacement value with a $500,000 deductible.
I admit it’s older building and have some maintenance issues ahead of us, but the dramatic switch from last year’s policy at $86,000, full replacement and a $25,000 deductible to a policy that is costing us $284,000 is horrifying to our owners.
Not only has this resulted in a 35 per cent increase in our strata fees but it has left us underinsured, with a deductible amount that no one will ever be able to cover, and a guarantee that we are essentially self-insured.
On the news of the insurance renewal, a sale collapsed last week, sending us into grave concerns that people won’t be able to renew mortgages. Our greatest concern is the loss limit. If we are only covered for 70 per cent of claims, and we have a $500,000 deductible, what is the point of insurance?
Colette W. Our industry has been experiencing an extraordinarily hard insurance market. The brokers who represent us take our policy along with our risks to the insurance industry to essentially negotiate your policy on your behalf, often with multiple insurers each taking a portion of the risk.
The insurance industry has seen a substantial increase in world claims and demands, significant increases in B.C. claims and losses on the investment markets. They are facing an aging housing stock that is prone to increased claims, and a reduced number of insurance companies are willing to assume the risks of the total loss and coverage for strata corporations in B.C.
Remember when an insurer covers your policy, they are not covering the likelihood of a leak damaging several units, they are covering the complete replacement value of your property, liability insurance, and perils such as water escape, flood, fire and our increasing earthquake risks.
Strata corporations in apartmentstyle buildings have a much higher risk of claims associated with multiple losses because of the proximity of all units, and the limits on containment.
Yes, the increases are dramatic. However, as a broker and insurer, they are looking at your exposure to risk. Your claims history plays a significant part in evaluating your risk, along with your subsequent actions.
Your property has experienced multiple claims since 2015 relating to water escape from older piping and your community has not approved the replacement of your piping that was identified in a 2017 report. Unfortunately, at this time of a difficult market, your strata corporation is likely in the highest risk category.
A 70 per cent loss limit does not apply to all claims. The loss limit applies to the total or negotiated loss in the event of damages that result in the event of demolition of your property. A claim that would amount to five per cent of your total value would be still fully covered, subject to any deductible amounts and limitations of the policy. Water and fire claims over $1,000,000 are not unusual in apartment-style buildings, so you can safely assume those would still be covered. With a high deductible rate, it is critical that you educate your owners on their responsibilities and liabilities.
Encourage all owners to purchase home owner insurance to cover the maximum amounts possible. Remind owners they could be liable for a claim if the loss is their responsibility as a result of an action or failure in their strata lot. Provide owners with a written reminder to run appliances such as laundry and dishwashers only when they are home and identify any other activities that may increase your risk such as barbecues on balconies, smoking, home alterations and upgrade installations that include water connections.
Most important, your strata corporation must renew your plumbing systems. You run the risk of no coverage available in the future if repeated claims relating to a failed building component are not remedied.
Note: Each week the Condominium Home owners Association is hosting a series of Tuesday Webinars open to the public on key strata and COVID-19 issues. Next week is managing insurance increases and loss limits, guest speaker Allyson Baker, Lawyer with Clark Wilson. To register go to choa.bc.ca and sign up for the E-update to receive weekly updates on new programs, guides and upcoming sessions.