Why Kendrick deserves a Pulitzer
These five songs reveal why jurors honoured Compton rapper’s album Some members of the classical-music world argue Kendrick Lamar doesn’t need more exposure.
Much of the reaction to Monday’s announcement that the Compton rapper Kendrick Lamar had won a Pulitzer Prize for music with his album Damn. amounted to something like: Finally.
A steadily strengthening force since its birth in the 1970s, aspects of hip hop have unquestionably dominated pop culture for years now — look at
Black Panther, look at Atlanta, look at Beyoncé last weekend at Coachella — which makes this recognition of one of its prime movers feel overdue at best.
Yet by selecting the 30-yearold Lamar, it’s not as though the Pulitzer committee was merely throwing an award to any prime mover it picked out of a hat.
Indeed, the backlash already seen online from some in the classical-music world — composers who believe that a famous rapper isn’t the one in need of more attention — suggests the jurors might have saved themselves the grief if they’d felt they could avoid it. (Perhaps they consulted the Nobel Prize people for reassurance after the latter were criticized by novelists and poets for giving Bob Dylan the prize for literature in 2016.)
Clearly, though, the Pulitzer committee encountered a musician in Lamar whose work demands honour in particular. Here are five of his songs, from Damn. and elsewhere, that demonstrate what the jurors heard.
“DNA” In singling out Lamar’s album, the Pulitzer organization praised Damn. for its “affecting vignettes capturing the complexity of modern AfricanAmerican life,” and nowhere is that complexity more palpable than in this cut about “the power, poison, pain and joy inside my DNA.” One of Lamar’s signatures on Damn. is jumping among different perspectives, but here he inhabits each with so much detail — from the 9-year-old living in a motel to the budding superstar “sipping from a Grammy” — that you understand the words not as role-play (though he can do that too) but as lived experience.
“Humble” Of course, words are only one component of Lamar’s music. The committee also drew attention to the “rhythmic dynamism” of Damn., which might be best exemplified by this funky yet hard-knocking single that hit No. 1 on Billboard’s Hot 100. On tour last year, Lamar sometimes presented “Humble” as an a cappella rap-along moment for his fans, who seemed to recite every word in perfect time — proof of a beat so strong that you can hear it even when it’s not playing. “Love” Lamar on Damn. isn’t always taking a wide view. For this disarming love song, the rapper zooms in on the day-to-day reality of a committed relationship with an intimacy that can be startling: “Bad attitude from your nanny / Curves and your hips from your mammy,” he raps, his tone as tender and playful as it is take-no-guff in “Humble.”
“These Walls” Lamar’s Pulitzer isn’t a lifetime-achievement award; it’s tied specifically to Damn. Yet prizes like this always signal the consideration of an artist’s entire body of work and, for Lamar, it seems likely that the jurors were impressed by his use of jazz textures and players — familiar terrain for the Pulitzers — in songs such as this one from 2015’s To Pimp a Butterfly album. Don’t miss the gorgeous electric-piano excursion about five minutes in.
“Swimming Pools (Drank)” One of several breakout tracks from Lamar’s 2012 major-label debut, good kid, m.A.A.d city, this woozy slow jam finds the rapper contemplating the risks of alcoholism for a young man who “grew up ’round some people living their life in bottles.” What distinguishes the song, beyond the way it makes unsteadiness into a kind of musical device, is how clear-eyed Lamar can be about someone’s failings even as he rejects the temptation to ridicule.