CHALLENGING CHINA
This politician is not one to shy away from a fish fight,
PANGANDARAN, INDONESIA— Susi Pudjiastuti was scooping up lunch with one hand, using her thumb and two fingers to extricate bones from a chunk of fish. With the other hand, she simulated grinding a stiletto heel into the ground.
“This is what I can do if the Chinese try to play tricks on me,” said Pudjiastuti, the maritime affairs and fisheries minister of Indonesia. “I can smile very nicely and then I can use my high heel.”
“Very sharp,” she added, popping the piece of fish into her mouth.
Suffice it to say that Pudjiastuti is not a conventional Indonesian woman, much less a conventional cabinet minister. She chain smokes, although Indonesia’s health minister — one of eight women in the cabinet of President Joko Widodo — has warned her that a public figure should not be seen lighting up.
Pudjiastuti likes her coffee black and her alcohol only in the form of champagne. “My family thinks I am a little bit of a nut case,” she said.
Perhaps it takes an unconventional type to challenge Beijing, going so far as to seize Chinese fishing boats poaching in Indonesian waters. She has created many enemies along the way, at home as well as abroad, but she says her success can be measured by the improved health of Indonesia’s fishing grounds, and she is not about to back down.
With more than13,000 islands, Indonesia is the world’s largest archipelagic nation, yet its maritime sovereignty had long been neglected. When she was appointed in 2014, Pudjiastuti, a seafood and aviation magnate who never finished high school, inherited a ministry that was in danger of being eliminated. But she has transformed her portfolio, declaring war on foreign fishing boats that had encroached on territorial waters and threatened some of the world’s most biodiverse seas.
Not all of the offenders have been from China. Boats from other Southeast Asian nations stray into Indonesia’s waters as well, costing the country more than a $1 billion a year in lost resources, the United Nations has reported. Pudjiastuti has not relied on subtlety: under her aegis, hundreds of impounded foreign vessels have been blown up.
But it is Pudjiastuti’s entanglements with the Chinese that have created the greatest uproar, while also making her an unlikely heroine for those calling for international defiance of Beijing’s muscular foreign policy.
Indonesia is not an official claimant to contested territory in the South China Sea, where Beijing is landing bombers on disputed islets. But the nine-dash line that China uses on maps to demarcate the swath of the South China Sea it considers its own nevertheless extends into waters that lap up against Indonesian islands. That is where the fish — and Pudjiastuti — come in. “I’m not the military, I’m not the foreign minister,” she said. “The Chinese cannot really get angry at me because all I’m talking about is fish.”
Another smile, another bite of lunch, this time doused in an incendiary sauce Pudjiastuti made from part of a 30-kilogram haul of chiles she bought during a recent trip to eastern Indonesia.
In June 2016, an Indonesian warship towed away a Chinese fishing boat that had been caught near the Natunas, Indonesian islands located in the southernmost reaches of the South China Sea. An attempt earlier that year to bring in another Chinese boat had been foiled when the Chinese Coast Guard intervened, severing the towing line connecting the impounded vessel to an Indonesian patrol boat.
Both seizures took place in waters that are well within Indonesia’s exclusive economic zone, as defined by international maritime law. But the Chinese Foreign Ministry protested and referred to the seas as China’s “traditional fishing grounds.”
Pudjiastuti was not impressed. “The Indonesians sailed all the way to Madagascar in ancient times,” she said.
“Should we claim the entire Indian Ocean as our ‘traditional fishing grounds’?”
Since Pudjiastuti took over, most of the 10,000 foreign fishing boats that once poached in Indonesian waters have disappeared. Fishing stocks more than doubled from 2013 to 2017, according to government statistics.
But earlier this year, Indonesia’s vice-president, Jusuf Kalla, said that enough was enough. Blowing up boats may have made Pudjiastuti the most beloved Indonesian cabinet minister, but the shock tactics were scaring off foreign investors. The Indonesian Chamber of Commerce echoed his complaint.
Even Indonesia’s 2.4-million-strong fishing community was up in arms, protesting Pudjiastuti’s efforts to halt popular but environmentally destructive practices like deep trawling and dynamite fishing.
The fisheries minister is unsympathetic. “When I started off in the seafood business, the fish were this big,” she said, widening her arms. “Then everything was small. The fish were gone, overfished, and the government didn’t care.”
Supporters have raised Pudjiastuti’s name as a possible vice-presidential running mate to Widodo, who is up for re-election next year, despite aconstitutional clause that limits the nation’s top two posts to candidates with a high school degree. Pudjiastuti demurred when asked to comment on the vice-presidential rumours.
Whenever she can, she returns to the sea. Earlier this year, Pudjiastuti and one of her housekeepers, Nurmadia Heremba, travelled to Pangandaran, the mangrove-fronted town where she grew up. It was a holiday weekend, and she decompressed by steering a paddleboard out to sea.
The current was strong but after 90 minutes of hard rowing Pudjiastuti relaxed on her paddleboard with a smoke and a hot drink. The setting sun glowed crimson over the Indian Ocean. “Screw Jakarta,” Pudjiastuti said. “I am happy when I am out at sea.”
“The Indonesians sailed all the way to Madagascar in ancient times. Should we claim the entire Indian Ocean as our ‘traditional fishing grounds’?” SUSI PUDJIASTUTI MARITIME AFFAIRS AND FISHERIES MINISTER OF INDONESIA