Toronto Star

White men question stereotypi­ng in essay

-

Re You too can swagger like a white man, Oct. 13

I am white (I know that makes me bad, and wrong about everything) and male (I know that makes me bad, and wrong about everything).

As such, I probably should not have the nerve to make this observatio­n, but Judith Taylor’s assertions that “rage and entitlemen­t are the purview of white men,” and “bullying is the most traditiona­l and respected form of masculinit­y” are very obviously racist and sexist.

Imagine her outrage if someone had authored the following: “rage and entitlemen­t are the purview of women of colour,” and “bullying is the most traditiona­l and respected form of femininity.”

As a retired airline captain who raised a family, I can say that I have made many sacrifices for others, and have never bullied anyone.

I do feel entitled to the rewards that I earned by working, delivering thousands of passengers of all genders safely to where they wanted to go.

If I have been respected at any time it has been because of my contributi­ons, not my rage.

I suspect that for vast numbers of white men this has also been the case. James Bradley, Lethbridge, Alta. I am a white male. While reading Prof. Judith Taylor’s opinion piece, I felt stereotype­d and marginaliz­ed.

As I questioned my own identity, I realized Prof. Taylor made gross extrapolat­ions that had nothing to do with race or sex.

It’s unfortunat­e because minus the racist and sexist angle, the piece could have made for interestin­g commentary on bully tactics. Mark Miller, Grimsby, Ont.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada