High stakes in Alberta
Throughout most of the 20th century and beyond, Canadians elsewhere in the country could serenely ignore provincial elections in Alberta, certain that voting day there would produce a walloping Social Credit or Progressive Conservative majority.
There were, granted, occasional alarms. Not least of which when the formidable Peter Lougheed put an end to the Socred dynasty in 1971 and — in response to PM-Trudeau-the-Elder’s National Energy Program — began flexing Alberta’s petromuscle to a chorus of “Let the Eastern bastards freeze in the dark.”
Usually, however, Alberta’s internal idiosyncracies provided the rest of the country with comic relief – from the thunderings of “Bible Bill” Aberhart, to the bafflements of Socred economics, to the rise of Ralph Klein as an outrageously populist Fordian prototype.
No longer can Canadians outside Alberta afford to avert their gaze.
Premier Rachel Notley, who this week called an election in Alberta for April16, pulled off an eye-popping upset four years ago to become head of that province’s first New Democratic Party government.
Now she is an endangered species, last of the women premiers of the past two decades.
Since Notley’s election, much has happened to alter the national and Alberta landscape.
The federal Conservatives of dour Stephen Harper were replaced by the sunny-way Liberals of Justin Trudeau.
Unite-the-Right, the sequel, saw the Progressive Conservatives merge with the Wildrose Party in July 2017 to become the United Conservative Party led by former Harperite Jason Kenney.
Alberta, in the Notley years, has engaged in border skirmishes and trade wars with British Columbia, threatening to turn off the oil taps (and banning B.C. wines) over its western neighbour’s inhospitality to the Trans Mountain pipeline.
In seeking a second mandate, Notley — who remains personally popular even as her New Democrats trail the UCP in most polls — has commenced a campaign that will have national consequences and from which federal players will draw lessons for the national vote soon to follow.
Climate change, the carbon tax, political corruption and racism are among the themes that will play large in both votes.
Notley remains committed to a carbon tax. “We can’t pretend that climate change isn’t there,” she has said. “We have an obligation as a world-leading energy producer to show leadership on it.”
But in 2018, after a federal court ruling that halted Trans Mountain, Notley withdrew from the federal carbon-pricing plan until shovels were back in the ground on the pipeline.
To be sure, she has a more complex message to sell on the file than Kenney — just as Trudeau will when he faces off against federal Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer.
“Any climate change plan that ignores working people is a plan doomed to fail,” she once tweeted. “Any economic plan that ignores climate change is setting our kids up to fail. We can tackle climate change and still protect our good energy industry jobs and that’s exactly what we’re going to do.”
For his part, Kenney markets much-easier-to-grasp hard verbs. End, halt, eliminate.
He has promised to scrap the carbon tax. In fact, he has said it would be the first act of a UCP government. He’s banking that Albertans, after having grown used to prosperity, are focused in these more trying times on the economy and jobs.
There can be little doubt that the hyper-partisanship of a Premier Jason Kenney would impact federal-provincial relations. It would embolden the right-wing Doug Fords and Scott Moes of Canada’s premierial class. And it would cause considerable discomfort to Trudeau, should he be re-elected. But Kenney carries his own burdens into the election. In January, a former Alberta MLA quit his local UCP board after complaining of backroom dealing, corruption and topdown control. The 2019 campaign was launched amid allegations that Kenney’s camp colluded with another candidate to undercut his chief rival in the UCP’s 2017 leadership race.
Notley plainly calculated that campaigning against a rival under ethical clouds offered her the best line of ascent on the uphill struggle to re-election.
“The larger picture is,” Notley said, in what she clearly hopes will become that fabled beast, the ballot question: “Who can you trust?”
Justin Trudeau will be watching, too, for fallout from such questions and from the resignation of a star UCP candidate over racist social media posts.
Caylan Ford reportedly lamented, in Facebook chat messages obtained by CBC News, that she was “saddened by the demographic replacement of white peoples in their homelands.”
She also reportedly wrote that there was a double standard for white supremacist terrorists and questioned whether LGBTQ parades had redeeming value.
Kenney had touted her as a “remarkable” candidate and the “personification of the new generation of leadership.” But as the campaign began, Kenney condemned the remarks.
Trudeau will surely be gauging the consequence of such views. In recent days, spotting an opportunity, he has attacked Scheer for such missteps as an appearance at a rally also attended by a white supremacist and a failure to immediately denounce the massacre in New Zealand for the anti-Muslim obscenity it was.
So stay tuned. In its themes if not its details, the Alberta election will in many ways be a preview for the federal campaign to come.