Supremacist donor controversy exposes fissures in Tory party
Conservatives to consider Sloan expulsion despite backing of right wing
OTTAWA—In attempting to expel a divisive MP, Erin O’Toole might have exposed more division within the Conservative movement.
By Tuesday morning, the Conservative leader had signed up more than 26 of his MPs to ask that Derek Sloan be expelled from their caucus after left-wing website Press Progress revealed Monday that Sloan received a campaign contribution from Paul Fromm, a self-proclaimed white nationalist. That’s enough caucus members to trigger a vote on Sloan’s position in the party, expected to come Wednesday morning.
But in an interview with the Star on Tuesday, Sloan, who denied knowing about the donation, said Conservative members have professed anger at O’Toole’s attempt to remove him — calling the donation issue “trumped-up charges.”
“When it comes to correspondence from constituents, from members across the country, it has been universally furious about this,” Sloan said.
“I think (this) risks the ire of many people, because I think pretty much everybody I’ve spoken to whether they’re social conservative or some other type just views this as being unfair … I think it’ll look bad, absolutely.”
O’Toole’s calls for Sloan’s expulsion did provoke some strong reactions — particularly from social conservatives.
“O’Toole does what he does at his peril,” said Jeff Gunnarson, executive director of the antiabortion group Campaign Life Coalition. “He can’t win much without social conservatives. “So, good luck.” O’Toole and his team know that the Conservatives’ small but vocal social conservative contingent hold significant power within the party — he was elected leader last year by courting that faction. In fact, O’Toole proudly advertised that he stuck up for Sloan’s participation in the leadership race after the rookie MP sparked controversy by questioning Dr. Theresa Tam’s loyalty to Canada.
At the same time, Conservatives know that ambiguous positioning on social issues — chiefly abortion and medically assisted dying rules, but also same-sex marriage — badly hurt former leader Andrew
Scheer with centrist swing voters in the 2019 election.
Two sources within the Conservative party characterized Sloan’s latest controversy as part of a pattern that has dogged the party.
The Star has also learned of a recent internal party spat between Sloan and the Conservatives’ most senior staffer, Executive Director Janet Fryday Dorey.
Two sources confirmed that Sloan made a series of robocalls and sent emails encouraging social conservatives to attend the party’s upcoming policy convention in March.
Fryday Dorey requested Sloan turn over the script of the calls and Sloan’s membership database
— a precious commodity in federal politics. Sloan refused, the two sources said, setting up a showdown between the rookie MP and Conservative headquarters.
When reached by the Star Tuesday, Sloan declined to discuss the episode. But a source with knowledge of Sloan’s thinking confirmed many of the details.
“I … confirm that we have been contacting members to for the purpose of having them sign up as delegates, (but) at all times we used our own list that we had generated through the leadership process, and we don’t believe we’ve broken any rules,” the source said.
When the Press Progress story
landed Monday, there was already bad blood between the party’s brass and the rookie MP. O’Toole quickly called for Sloan’s expulsion, but the Reform Act mechanisms leave that decision with the caucus.
O’Toole has yet to hold a media availability to discuss his decision, as the Conservatives prepare for a caucus meeting Wednesday.
Whether or not Sloan, the MP for Hastings-Lennox and Addington, will be at that retreat remains to be seen.
Sloan, who ran a controversial campaign for the leadership, has not won many friends among the federal caucus members who hold his fate in their hands.