Judge bars several accusers from testifying at Cosby’s trial
In a major break for Bill Cosby, a judge ruled Friday that just one of the comedian’s multitude of other accusers can testify at his trial to bolster charges he drugged and violated a woman more than a decade ago.
The 79-year-old TV star is set to go on trial in June, accused of sexually assaulting former Temple University employee Andrea Constand at his suburban Philadelphia home in 2004. Prosecutors wanted to put 13 other women on the stand to show his alleged conduct was part of a distinct pattern of behaviour.
Montgomery County Judge Steven O’Neill disallowed all but one of those women, saying in a one-page ruling that he carefully weighed the possible value of their testimony against the potential prejudice to Cosby.
The one witness who can testify says the TV star drugged
and assaulted her in 1996 at a Los Angeles hotel.
With O’Neill’s ruling, the trial will now rest more heavily than ever on Constand’s credibility.
“There is an obvious value to the prosecution when you have numerous accusers. That alone
adds tremendous weight to the case,” said lawyer Joseph McGettigan, a prosecutor in the Penn State sex abuse scandal.
The ruling could also shave weeks off the trial.
Cosby, who is free on US$1 million bail, could get 10 years in prison if convicted. He is expected in court again Monday to ask that the jurors be selected from another county because of the heavy publicity.
Prosecutors compiled the list of 13 potential witnesses from the nearly 50 women who have come forward in recent years to say they were drugged and molested – a barrage that destroyed Cosby’s good-guy reputation as the star of TV’s “Cosby Show” in the 1980s.
His lawyers objected to the testimony about “prior bad acts,” saying that in some cases the sex was consensual, while others involved former models and actresses falsely accusing Cosby to gain money or attention.
His attorneys also argued that some the allegations were so vague – with some of the women unsure of when the alleged encounters even took place – that it would be impossible for Cosby to defend himself.