Ending NAFTA would be ‘devastating’

OTTAWA — Tearing up the North American Free Trade Agreement will mean lost jobs in all three member countries, says the head of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

But Tom Donahue also said there are ways to improve the 23-year-old trade deal between Canada, Mexico and the United States and there’s potential to create a stronger agreement that will improve North America’s overall competitiveness with the rest of the world.

Donahue, who was critical of U.S. President Donald Trump before he was elected, came to Ottawa on Monday with a largely conciliatory message about the need to move forward constructively on bettering the economies of NAFTA’s three countries.

He told an audience of business leaders, politicians and diplomats that the intertwined and integrated economies of Canada, the United States and Mexico are a good thing that must be preserved.

The message was largely in sync with the approach Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government has taken toward the Trump administration: stressing the deep economic ties and the fact that millions of U.S. jobs also depend on NAFTA. Donahue was to meet Trudeau and his advisers later on Monday.

“First, let’s do no harm,” said Donahue.

Trump has threatened to abandon NAFTA if it can’t be renegotiated to his satisfaction.

“Let me say right up front that withdrawing from NAFTA would be devastating for the workers, businesses and economies of our three countries,” Donahue said.

Canada and Mexico have become the two top U.S. export markets since 1994, he said.

While the rules of the agreement need to be modernized and improved, that should not “disrupt” the $1.3 trillion in trade between the three countries, he said.

NAFTA’s visa provisions need to be upgraded to allow more movement for skilled workers, he added.

He also dismissed the possibility of NAFTA being replaced with separate bilateral agreements with the United States — something Canada has said it would be open to — saying that would give rise to “divergent rules” that would raise the cost of doing business, “destroy jobs and hob-

ble our industries.”

He said the U.S. business leaders would fight hard at the NAFTA negotiating table for its “shared priorities.”

The day after Trump’s victory, Canada announced it would be willing to renegotiate NAFTA to make it stronger.

Donahue’s Canadian counterpart, Perrin Beatty, called on the Trudeau government to begin consultations with businesses on the way forward on NAFTA.

Beatty said Canada will enter the talks from a position of strength because nine million American jobs and 35 U.S. states also depend on the deep trading links.

“I don’t expect Congress will do things to do a favour for Canada,” he said. “But they’ll listen to their own business community and their own business community sends a message loud and clear that it’s essential that we build the relationship, not that we dismantle it.”