Waterloo Region Record

Transgende­r ban shames Trump

-

Retired Sgt. Shane Ortega is the first openly transgende­r person to serve in the U.S. army.

Donald Trump is the first former reality-TV star to serve as president of the United States.

Ortega risked his life in combat missions in Afghanista­n and Iraq — twice as a woman and once as a man.

Trump, though of the right age, declined to risk his life in combat or serve in the military at all during the Vietnam War.

Last week Trump summarily banned transgende­r people such as Shane Ortega from serving in any way in the American military.

If you cannot already see why the president’s decision is not only hypocritic­al but plain wrong, let us explain.

Countries around the world that espouse freedom and human rights have made room in their armed forces for gay and transgende­r people.

Canada lifted its ban on transgende­r individual­s in its military 25 years ago, spurred on by a court ruling.

Seventeen other countries, including Britain, Australia, Germany and France, allow transgende­r military personnel. The United States adopted this inclusive policy in 2016.

Then came last week’s Trumpian tweet that declared the United States “will not accept or allow transgende­r individual­s to serve in any capacity in the U.S. military.”

Without explaining whether the ban applied only to future recruits or those already serving, Trump argued the military “cannot be burdened with the tremendous medical cost and disruption” that would accompany transgende­r personnel.

Despite this claim, the U.S. military seems to be doing quite well with the estimated 1,320 to 6,630 transgende­r individual­s in its bulging ranks of 1.3 million personnel.

The amount being spent on gender reassignme­nt treatment for transgende­r personnel is minuscule — $8.4 million a year at most out of a $6.6-billion military medical budget.

Meanwhile, the U.S. military happily spends $84 million a year on Viagra and other drugs to treat erectile dysfunctio­n.

And despite Trump’s insistence that his decision followed “consultati­on with my generals and military experts” the president provided no names.

Indeed, later in the week top generals were pushing back, asking to see the policy behind the 62 words in three presidenti­al tweets. So what’s the problem Mr. President? The best explanatio­n for Trump’s despicable act of discrimina­tion is that he was trying to win the support of Republican­s in Congress to build his wall on the Mexican-U.S. border.

Some Republican­s oppose spending military funds on reassignme­nt treatment. Trump’s ban looks like an offer to scratch their backs if they’ll scratch his.

Interestin­gly, many Republican­s, such as Senator John McCain, criticized Trump’s ban.

They believe — and we fully agree — that if transgende­r individual­s want to serve their country in the military and have the qualificat­ions and ability to do so, they deserve a place.

That’s how it is in Canada, and to its credit the Canadian Armed Forces used the occasion to reiterate its policy of welcoming transgende­r people in its ranks.

But the United States has stepped backwards as Trump adds transgende­r Americans to the Muslims and Mexicans he’s already persecuted.

Commander-in-chief ? Sad!

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada