Selanne’s a lock, but who else will join hockey hall?
With few major names joining the field, stars of yesteryear could get second look
Many people complain about the traffic snarl in the Hockey Hall of Fame’s veteran player parking lot, but only a few can do something to untangle it — only once a year and only after any deserving first-year eligibles are taken care of.
That opportunity to clear a backlogged name or two comes Monday in Toronto when the 18-member hall selection committee gathers. While they can accept suggestions from hockey brethren or receive entreaties from the public throughout the calendar year, only a committee member can put a name forward and then make a case for the 75 per cent vote needed for induction among peers.
In 2016, considered one of the more open fields in past years, there was room after Eric Lindros and Sergei Makarov to add threetime Stanley Cup winning goaltender and Canada Cup champion Rogatien Vachon, almost four decades after his retirement. The latter said he’d just about given up on getting a hall call, but his inclusion has renewed hope for others.
Teemu Selanne, the 15th-highest scorer in league history with a batch of trophies, is considered a lock to be announced in his first year, one of four spots open in the player category, including up to two female candidates.
Of 14 skaters joining the waiting list this year with a common link of 1,000 NHL regular season games, 300 goals, 400 assists or 700 points, three besides Selanne have improved chances as winners of a Cup or Olympic gold medal: Daniel Alfredsson, Alex Kovalev and Ray Whitney. Among goalies, Nikolai Khabibulin comes in with 333 wins, 46 shutouts and a Cup and Olympic gold.
Beyond Selanne, there aren’t any surefire picks, perhaps opening a crack for a lengthy list of players that go back to the Original Six. Many arguments have been heard through the years on behalf of multi-Cup winners Claude Provost (nine), Jean-Guy Talbot (seven) and Ralph Backstrom, Larry Hillman and Kevin Lowe (six each). It follows the narrative that not just points make a player hall-worthy.
It’s believed one of the strongest pushes behind the scenes this year was for four-time champion Butch Goring. A veteran centre of 16 seasons as the two-way demon for the Islanders dynasty, Goring took just 102 penalty minutes in 1,107 games while notching 40 short-handed goals.
Like Selanne, Goring won the Calder Trophy, later adding the Conn Smythe and Lady Byng to his collection. He retired in 1985 as the 27th-highest scorer in the league, with the 26 players ahead of him all eventually getting in. Contributions before his NHL days, such as a Calder Cup win, and afterward in the media, are part of his case.
Goring would have played against a few members of the selection committee such as Bobby Clarke, Mike Gartner and chairman John Davidson and been coached against by Scotty Bowman, who might be in his or someone else’s corner. But the committee is also comprised of writers (Michael Farber, Eric Duhatschek, Marc de Foy), broadcasters (Bob McKenzie), junior hockey reps (Dave Branch), NHL managers (Brian Burke, Bill Torrey) and former European players (Anders Hedberg, Igor Larionov and Jari Kurri) with the goal of keeping an open mind to all names put forward.
Individual committee members are not permitted to make public comments about their deliberations before or after the annual meeting and the ensuing announcement.
The committee will get younger as time goes on, which could mean players such as Goring will face even longer waits as more names in the 21st century end their careers. Up to two people in the builders’ wing can be chosen with the four players unless one or more referees and linesmen are approved in the officials’ category.
Here are some other names denied a hall pass so far:
Mark Recchi: 1,533 points, 12th in all-time NHL scoring, three Cups, one world championship
Dave Andreychuk: 640 goals (14th in NHL history), 1,338 points, one Cup
Chris Osgood: 401 wins in goal, three Cups
Brian Bellows, 1,022 points, one Stanley Cup, one Canada Cup
Boris Mikhailov, 169 world championship points, eight world titles, two Olympic gold medals
Anatoli Firsov, 101 world championship points, three Olympic gold medals
Rod Brind’Amour, 1,184 points, one Stanley Cup, one world championship
Paul Kariya, 989 points, one Olympic and one world championship
Beyond Selanne, there aren’t any surefire picks, perhaps opening a crack for a lengthy list of players that go back to the Original Six.