Brazil stunned by wild soccer brawl
Violent clashes between local fans leave Cup host reeling
Brazil pledged to stamp out stadium violence on Monday after hooliganism marred a weekend first division league game, raising fresh doubts about its ability to stage a trouble-free World Cup.
President Dilma Rousseff said Brazil could not and would not tolerate soccer violence after fans of Atletico Paranaense and Vasco da Gama fought pitched battles in the southern city of Joinville.
Graphic television footage showed hundreds of fans of both sides kicking and punching for several minutes with the game only a few minutes old, forcing the referee to call a halt for an hour as order was belatedly restored.
The violence continued unabated as the hooligans ran amok, clashing in several sections of the stands.
At least three fans were hurt with one, who is believed to have suffered a fractured skull, airlifted to safety by helicopter.
There was further controversy after police failed to intervene and it later transpired Atletico had only drafted private security personnel to ‘police’ a “private event”.
Rousseff was forthright in her condemnation. “A footballing country cannot live with violence in its stadiums. This violence goes against all that we associate with football,” the president said.
“The presence of police is necessary in stadiums,” she said.
Sports Minister Aldo Rebelo also condemned the violence and vowed his ministry would be asking why military police had not been on hand.
“Those responsible must be identified and punished,” Rebelo said.
And Andrei Rodrigues, a justice ministry official dealing with security during major events, said what happened in Joinville “will not happen again during the World Cup”.
Stressing the weekend league match was not under FIFA control, he told a media conference: “What I can say is that this is not the model of security that will be used during the World Cup.
“We have an integrated security scheme in which private security will work in tandem with public authorities with respect to ticket control, searches of spectators and identification of people,” he said.
“Each of the ( 12) World Cup host arenas will be monitored by 200 cameras in real time, with clear intervention plans.”
On Sunday, FIFA said it regretted any form of soccer violence but said it should have no impact on the World Cup.
“However, for the 2014 FIFA
Each of the (12) World Cup host arenas will be monitored by 200 cameras in real time, with clear intervention plans.” ANDREI RODRIGUES JUSTICE MINISTRY OFFICIAL
World Cup a very comprehensive security concept is in place in an integrated operation between private and public security authorities to ensure the safety for fans, players and any other stakeholder involved in the event,” a spokesperson said.
Brazilian media expressed consternation at an admission by state authorities that security inside the ground was left in the hands of private security with state police only on duty outside.
“The forces of law and order intervened later because security at the match was under the responsibility of a private company employed by Atletico,” said police spokesman Adilson Moreira.
A spokeswoman for Santa Catarina state’s public prosecutor said “this was an isolated case” and that normally police would be expected to be inside the stadium rather than just outside.
Only after the fans had been left to their own violent devices did security forces wielding guns and firing rubber bullets intervene.
Atletico was playing the match in Joinville, about 135 kilometers south of its home city of Curitiba — which will host World Cup action next year — following previous disorder.
Brazilian television showed players, some clearly in shock, and coaching staff appealing for calm.
One Atletico player was in tears as he looked on incredulously at prostrate fans being kicked in the head and beaten.
“I have been playing for 20 years and I have never seen anything like this in person. We will have a World Cup in our country and we know these images will be shown everywhere,” defender Luiz Alberto said.
The violence was the last thing Brazil needed as it struggles to prepare the 12 host venues for the World Cup with at least three stadiums still running behind schedule, including Sao Paulo, slated to host the opening match on June 12.
Following its defeat, Vasco da Gama was relegated from the elite division.
Also going down on what Lance sports daily dubbed a “barbarous” day for the game was fellow Rio de Janeiro team Fluminense — last year’s champion.
“It is regrettable to see these type of things at this time when everyone is talking about the next World Cup in the country,” said Vasco technical director Adilson Batista.