Tesla becomes most valuable US carmaker, edging out GM
Analyst's glowing report sends company's value soaring
For the first time in the era of the modern automobile, the most valuable US carmaker is not based in Detroit.
Silicon Valley’s Tesla Inc overtook General Motors on Monday to become the US carmaker with the largest market capitalization as the century-old automobile industry increases its reliance on software and cutting-edge energy technology.
That milestone is likely to be on the minds of Tesla Chief Executive Elon Musk and GM Chief Executive Mary Barra as they and other CEOs visited the White House on Tuesday to discuss tax reform and infrastructure with President Donald Trump.
Its market value of $50.887 billion exceeded GM’s by about $1 million.
In March, the luxury electric car maker has surged 35 percent as investors bet that Musk will revolutionize the automobile and energy industries.
That compares to a declining share performance by GM in recent years that recently led billionaire investor David Einhorn to propose splitting the stock into two classes to help boost its price.
Tesla’s market capitalization is now equivalent to $102,000 for every car it plans to make in 2018, or $667,000 per car sold last year. By comparison, GM’s market capitalization is equivalent to $5,000 per car it sold in 2016.
The Palo Alto, California company is rushing to launch its mass-market Model 3 sedan in the second half of 2017 and quickly ramp up its factory to reach a production target of 500,000 cars per year in 2018.
In 2016, it sold 76,230, missing its target of at least 80,000 vehicles. By comparison, GM sold 10 million cars and Ford sold 6.7 million.
With its stock down nearly 20 percent since 2013, GM has scaled back operations outside the US while pushing to improve its profitability. It announced in March it would sell its European operations.
Reflecting Wall Street’s worries, GM’s stock trades at six times its expected earnings, the lowest multiple among companies in the S&P 500.
Proponents believe Tesla, which is not profitable, argue its stock price is justified based on long-term expectations for Tesla’s growth.
They also point to opportunities from Tesla’s acquisition last year of money-losing solar panel installer SolarCity and Tesla’s Nevada battery cell plant aimed at driving down manufacturing costs.
One enthusiastic analyst
After driving a Tesla for seven months, Piper Jaffray analyst Alexander Potter on Monday upgraded the stock to “overweight” from “neutral,” describing Tesla’s products as “captivating.”
“Tesla isn’t just another company. More so than any stock we’ve covered, Tesla engenders optimism, freedom, defiance, and a host of other emotions that, in our view, other companies cannot replicate,” Potter wrote in a Piper Jaffray report.
Skeptics believe Tesla’s growth targets are unrealistic and that the company risks being overtaken by GM, Ford and other deep-pocketed manufacturers ramping up their own offerings of electric vehicles.
Its market capitalization remains smaller than Japan’s Toyota Motor Corp, at $173 billion.
Tesla’s rich valuation has made it a target of short sellers, who so far in 2017 have suffered over $2 billion in paper losses as the stock rallied.
Jeffrey Gundlach, who oversees over $105 billion in assets at Los Angeles-based DoubleLine Capital, told Reuters last week: “As a car company alone, Tesla is crazy high valuation. As a battery company – one that expands and innovates substantially – maybe the valuation can work.”