Closing the gates
Fed up with mass tourism, hotspots take away welcome mat
“Never again a summer like this.” Exasperated with the hordes of visitors they blame for making their city unlivable, Barcelona residents have risen in protest.
The hugely popular Catalan metropolis has become the latest European hotspot to eye tourism with hostility.
From the romantic canals of Venice to the walled mediaeval town of Dubrovnik via the wilderness of Scotland’s Isle of Skye, tourism is morphing into a nightmare for many locals, despite the jobs and income it undoubtedly generates.
In the trendy seaside Barceloneta district of Barcelona, residents have for years complained about anti-social behavior like drunkenness and sex in public areas, as well as a leap in rental prices that has forced many locals out.
“We don’t want tourists in our buildings,” read banners in a protest over the weekend, in which dozens of locals took to a beach that draws revelers from all over the world.
Similar demonstrations have flared in other parts of Spain, the world’s third tourism destination.
This summer in Palma de Majorca in the popular Balearic Islands, activists burst into the port, setting off flares of red smoke and throwing confetti over people eating at a restaurant.
Others assaulted a bus full of tourists in Barcelona, painting over its windscreen and giving passengers a fright.
Beyond these protests, officials too have started addressing the problem of overcrowding.
The Balearic Islands, for instance, have just limited to just over 623,000 the number of visitors that can stay in hotels or legal rental accommodation in one go.
‘Not the enemy’
Faced with the protests and criticism, Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy was forced to defend a sector that counts for 11 percent of Spain’s economic growth.
“I never thought I would have to defend the Spanish tourism sector, it’s really unprecedented,” he said earlier this month.
Tourism is a major source of growth outside of Spain too.
According to the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO), one in 10 jobs worldwide is tied to a sector that generates 10 percent of global GDP.
“Tourism is not the enemy,” UNWTO chief Taleb Rifai said.
From 1995 to 2016, the number of international travelers went from 525 million to 1.2 billion thanks to low-cost companies and visitors from emerging markets like China, India and the Gulf countries.
As a result, some destinations are now sagging under the weight of tourists.
Dubrovnik in Croatia is a favorite with cruiseships – a popularity that soared even further when it was used as a backdrop in the smash TV series Game of Thrones.
The walled old town is a delight of 17th- and 18th-century architecture. Locals, though, do their best to avoid it, saying it is almost impossible to move in the congestion.
“Sometimes to enter the old part of town, you need to queue for an hour in 40 C heat,” says 27-year-old Ana Belosevic, who works in the hotel business.
Mayor Mato Frankovic said that cameras have been set up to monitor the number of people entering the old town and authorities plan to reduce the number of cruiseships coming into the port.
Similar measures have also been taken on the other side of the Adriatic Sea in Venice, which counts 265,000 inhabitants for around 24 million visitors annually.
Authorities there have decided to trial a system that forces visitors to make a reservation if they want to go to the popular Saint Mark’s Square during peak hours.
Tourists will also be fined 500 euros ($585) if they have picnics or bathe in the canals.
In Florence, meanwhile, authorities have started hosing down public spots such as church steps where many visitors congregate to eat picnics, to stop them from sitting down.
Tourism drop
One of the solutions to overcrowding is to encourage visitors to go to less visited districts, thus easing up city centers, says Rafat Ali, founder of the Skift travel information website.
But this has merely expanded the problem to districts that were once tourist-free.
In Lisbon, the boom in visitors has had a signifi-
cant impact on residents in its oldest district, Alfama, which is now full of tourism flats that raise property prices.
“Now in Alfama it’s difficult to find places to rent for less than 1,000 euros a month, a huge amount if you take into account the salary of a Portuguese person, which is normally lower than that,” says Maria de Lurdes Pinheiro, head of a local heritage association.
Even further north in Scot- land’s remote Isle of Skye, the wild landscape is attracting an increasing number of visitors.
So much so that residents have started complaining about the number of tourists on the island’s few roads, environmental damage and a lack of accommodation.
Rifai warns though against saying no to tourism.
“The same people that today are saying we don’t want any more tourism are going to be the first ones to cry out when we lose them,” he said this week. Turkey is a prime example. There, authorities are desperate to boost a sector key to the economy that slumped due to a failed coup d’etat and attacks in 2016, when tourism revenue fell almost 30 percent.
“Too much tourism is a good problem to have,” says Rafat Ali.
“The worst is if nobody comes.”