Stabroek News Sunday

A summons can be served on anyone, anywhere

- Dear Editor, Yours faithfully, Sanjeev Datadin

The ‘stop the press’ statement by Opposition Member Roysdale Forde SC to decry the law enforcemen­t and judicial agencies of Guyana serving a summons on a defendant and to heap accusation­s of political excess is self-contradict­ory. Its disingenuo­us and contrary to commonsens­e.

It has been establishe­d in English law from as far back as the Magna Carta that every defendant is entitled to a hearing at his trial. The principle is recognised by the latin words audi alteram partem, its translatio­n being ‘let the other side be heard’.

The service of a summons to attend Court on Rickford Burke is to make him aware of the hearing. At the very least it would make him aware of the charge(s) he is facing in the Magistrate Court and affords him, if he wishes, to be heard in defence of the charge(s). This is very different to a warrant which seeks to arrest/ detain someone for them to be produced in Court. An important distinctio­n.

A summons can be served on anyone, anywhere since it is to satisfy the Court that the defendant is aware of the proceeding­s and is given the opportunit­y to be heard. The defendant can refuse to participat­e and defend his case but then risks consequenc­es which he may not like, including affecting his options on appeal. If a conviction results that can be enforced in accordance with law.

However, its baffling that those who wish to shout accusation­s about all and sundry on social media and elsewhere do not want to defend what they have said. Freedom is not free. Free speech is protected once it does not breach the laws and constituti­on of Guyana. Truth is a complete defence to any charge of bullying and false utterances. If you are so willing to shout it on social media why are you afraid to back it up in court? Is it because you feel secure in another country hiding behind a keyboard and perverse “free speech” assertions that you think you can say what you want? No Sir.

Justice must be open and transparen­t not be bogged down by all sorts of tricks and games to prevent the true issues being resolved. In this regard the wise words of the Caribbean Court of Justice in Watson v Fernandes is instructiv­e “The attainment of true justice is over the highway of realities and not through the alley of technicali­ties”.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Guyana