LedgerXwill transform cryptocurrencies
Clearing house for derivatives contracts paves way for digital money to be officially accepted
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission granted LedgerX — a cryptocurrency trading platform — registration as a clearing house for derivatives contracts settling in digital currencies. This indicates increasing official acceptance of cryptocurrencies. More important, the move could redefine them.
Derivatives clearing houses catalyse enormous economic change. The creation of agricultural futures clearing houses in the mid-19th century American West transformed a sparsely populated backwater into ground zero for the second Industrial Revolution. In the same place exactly 125 years later, on April 26, 1973, financial options clearing houses gave birth to the modern global derivatives economy.
The key features of derivatives clearing houses are centrally cleared, collateralised, asset-settled contracts with mark-to-market margin. Existing cryptocurrency futures and options have none of those characteristics — they are merely side bets; LedgerX has the first three, which may be enough to transmute cryptocurrencies.
Consider cryptocurrency renters, users and investors. Renters buy cryptocurrency for a transaction, say, an international payment to someone in a financially repressed country. In effect, they pay transaction fees for payment processing services. Users both pay and receive in cryptocurrencies, and maintain balances for transactional purposes. Investors buy cryptocurrencies but don’t use them.
If LedgerX succeeds in creating a high-volume, liquid exchange, investors are likely to be the first adopters. Today there is no convenient way to short cryptocurrencies or to take levered positions in them. Buying call or put options meets these needs.
Investors are also natural option sellers. Instead of buying one bitcoin, for example, an investor can get similar exposure by writing two atthe-money put options, or buying two bitcoins and writing at-the-money calls on them. This is more complicated than just buying one bitcoin and the positions need to be rebalanced, but the demand for options should make the expected return higher for taking the same economic exposure. Moreover, LedgerX offers a facility for intermediaries to offer cryptocurrency-exposed accounts with the same advantages for less sophisticated investors.
The natural trade of cryptocurrency users is to write atthe-money call options and buy atthe-money puts on their holdings. But this would require them to post their cryptocurrency as collateral, so they could not use it.
A reasonable alternative is to write at-the-money (say $2,800 for bitcoin) call options on half their holdings, and use the premium to buy puts on their entire holdings at a strike of perhaps $2,000 for bitcoin. They give up half the appreciation on their holdings plus tie up half of it in collateral, in exchange for a floor price to protect them against a crash.
This could touch off a virtuous cycle. More investors are attracted to cryptocurrencies due to availability of leverage and shorting, plus enhanced returns for passive unlevered investors.