No conflict of interest in Supreme Energy stake sale: Deepak Kochhar
Says Sup re me’ s stake in Nu Power was sold to Pinnacle Trust at market rates, including~640-million loan
When Deepak Kochhar’s Pinnacle Trust bought the stake held by Venugopal Dhoot’s Supreme Energy in NuPower in 2010, the deal came with a liability of a ~640 million loan.
Kochhar, currently managing director (MD) of NuPower Renewables, is in the middle of a controversy involving his wife and ICICI Bank MD and CEO Chanda Kochhar’s alleged conflict of interest in being part of a committee that approved the loan to Dhoot’s Videocon group. “When Pinnacle Trust bought the stake of Supreme Energy, it included a liability of ~640 million. The purchase was at a fair market value (prevailing price) of ~8.80 per share,” Deepak Kochhar said in a telephonic conversation with Business Standard. He denied any conflict of interest in the stake sale by Supreme Energy to Pinnacle Trust.
NuPower got a loan of ~640 million (as fully convertible debentures) in 2010 from Supreme Energy, which was 99.9 per cent owned by Dhoot, chairman of the Videocon group. Supreme Energy held the majority stake in NuPower till March 2010. Kochhar was co-promoter of NuPower, along with Dhoot.
According to regulatory filings, Dhoot sold his entire stake in NuPower to Mahesh Chandra Punglia, and this was later transferred for ~900,000 to Pinnacle Trust, in which Kochhar is a managing trustee.
NuPower’s website says the company has 700 Mw of wind power capacity.
But Kochhar has said NuPower only has 180 Mw of operational projects. He also said that the balance — which the website says is under construction — were actually just identified locations for prospective projects. “The 520 Mw do not stand anymore, as the government announced competitive bidding in the wind sector. NuPower doesn’t own them nor has any real estate or anything related to these projects,” Kochhar told the paper.
In 2016, Kochhar had told various media outlets that their company was planning 500 Mw of wind power projects in Tamil Karnataka,· Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh through the feed-in tariff model. The model allowed firms to install projects by identifying sites and deciding on tariffs through the electricity regulator. Three years ago, NuPower was also trying to sell 400 Mw of under-construction projects, but had no success. Two leading wind sector players said NuPower had approached them with a valuation of ~1.7-1.8 billion, which was too high. The company stopped looking for buyers after that.
The introduction of competitive bidding in 2017 retired the feed-in tariff methodology.
In March last year, NuPower transferred 100 Mw of its operational capacity to Echanda Urja, a special purpose vehicle (SPV) named after his wife. It was formed to sell wind power under the Renewable Energy Certificate (REC) scheme. Kochhar, through NuPower, has a 70.01 per cent stake in Echanda Urja. Some of the 10 other partners are Hatsun Agro (6.11 per cent), Motherson Sumi (1.66 per cent), Shri Govindaraja Textiles (6.55 per cent), Dhandapani Cement, Loyal Textiles, CavinKare and Zuari Cement, according to Echanda Urja’s filings with the Registrar of Companies as on March 2017.
The Echanda Urja SPV is part of a group captive scheme that has 10 other partners. A group captive scheme is where a company develops a power plant for collective usage by many commercial consumers. The developer should have at least 26 per cent of the equity and has to consume at least 51 per cent of the power produced.
There is another SPV called NuPower Wind Farms. This sells RECs too, but the volume of power traded is not available.
Another subsidiary, NuPower Technology, set up in Gujarat to assemble wind turbines and generators in India, is also defunct, according to company sources. When enquired, its directors said the firm had no manufacturing plans. This subsidiary registered a turnover of ~4.5 million and loss of ~117.8 million in 2014-15.
NuPower Renewables was profitable till 2011, after which it suddenly went into the red. From making a profit of ~59 million in 2010-11, it suffered a loss of ~83 million the next year. In 2012-13, it had a loss of ~69 million.
This was the last figure the firm reported. In 2012, the Centre withdrew all tax benefits given to the wind sector, hitting the top lines of many companies. NuPower Renewables has a 30 Mw wind power project in Maharashtra, which it sells through a power-purchase agreement with the state’s discom.
The plant was built end-to-end on self-development basis by NuPower Renewables, according to a media statement dated November 29, 2015.