Even as realty sector lags, large listed developers gain share
Most large players reported better than expected booking sin the September quarter; Oberoi and Sun te ck the least lever aged
Major players report better than expected bookings in the September quarter. RAM PRASAD SAHU writes
The BSE Realty sector has been one of the biggest losers among sectoral indices in 2018 so far, down over 38 per cent. About half of that loss has come over the last couple of months due to the liquidity problems facing non-banking financial companies (NBFCs). Construction financing was helping sustain the real estate sector amid slow movement of inventory and muted cash flows. The importance of NBFC funding can be gauged from the fact that while credit to the sector from banks grew at just under 5 per cent, NBFC funding increased at the rate of 45 per cent during FY14-18.
While the NBFC issue will severely constrain cash flows of real estate companies, brokerages believe it is an opportunity for investors to increase or take an exposure to the larger listed realty players. Though analysts expect stock prices to be volatile, they recommend buying companies with balance sheet strength and strong execution capabilities.
Abhishek Anand of JM Financial says, “A strong balance sheet would not only help companies face short-term liquidity constraints, but also expand portfolios with favourably valued deals.” He picks Oberoi Realty and Godrej Properties as the companies to bet on in the sector.
A squeeze and an opportunity While the sectoral headwinds (note ban, GST, RERA) have squeezed out smaller players, there has in fact been an opportunity for larger players to increase their top-line growth and acquire projects at attractive rates. Sales of larger listed players have grown 29 per cent as compared to 2 per cent fall for the real estate sector in the June quarter, say Murtuza Arsiwalla and Samrat Verma of Kotak Institutional Equities. Even in the September quarter, barring a couple, most large real estate companies have reported a 20 per cent-plus growth in sales. Given the higher growth, the market
share of the top listed players has gone up to 39 per cent in June 2018 as compared to 21 per cent a year ago, says the brokerage.
In a post-result call with investors, Vikas Oberoi, chairman and managing director of Oberoi Realty, indicated that this (NBFC crisis) is a positive for the company as there is less resistance/competition when it is looking at buying land parcels. Analysts say as has been the case with other sectors, the organised segment will benefit by taking market share from smaller players who are stuck with inventory and high working capital requirements.
Leverage in focus
While there has not been a significant improvement in demand outlook, the Street is expected to give a premium to developers who have a lighter balance sheet. While most listed large real estate players have a healthy balance sheet and good sales growth, which should help improve their market share, companies with the lowest leverage include Oberoi Realty, Suntech Realty and Mahindra Life.
Even for large realty majors, such as Sobha, which are leveraged with net debt to equity at 1.15 times as of September 2018 quarter, sales growth has been on an upward trend and cost of funding is coming down. Sobha has maintained a project launch guidance of 18 million square feet, which is a combination of new and existing projects, enabling it to achieve its FY19 annual sales guidance of 3-4 million square feet. On the debt side, the company indicated that NBFCs accounted for only 14 per cent of its borrowings, with a majority coming from non-convertible debentures and bank loans. Its overall cost of borrowing, which has been declining for the last 13 quarters, is pegged at 9.3 per cent.
Analysts at SBICAP Research have singled out Sobha as their top pick in the real estate sector due to its steady execution and high earnings visibility, driven by new launches and strong order book in the contractual segment. Brokerages are also bullish about prospects for the largest domestic real estate player DLF, which has reported a cash flow breakeven in the September quarter helping it to maintain a flat debt on a sequential basis. DLF says it will be a zero net debt company by the end of the fiscal year on the back of fund infusion by promoters and raising fresh capital. Given the better than expected new bookings in the first half of the fiscal, the company believes it can beat the ~20-~22.5 billion new booking annual guidance.