CITIZENSHIP BILL WILL BE JINNAH’S WIN OVER GANDHI: THAROOR
Govt comfortably placed to ensure passage of Bill in both Houses; Oppn chalks out protest plans
The passage of the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill in Parliament will mark the definitive victory of Mohammed Ali Jinnah’s thinking over that of Mahatma Gandhi’s, senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor said on Sunday, asserting that the exercise of granting citizenship on the basis of religion will reduce India to a “Hindutva version of Pakistan”. The former Union minister also alleged that the BJP government wanted to single out “one community” and refused to grant its members asylum from oppression on the same conditions as other communities.
Home Minister Amit Shah will introduce the Citizenship Amendment Bill in the Lok Sabha on Monday, the House list of business released on Sunday stated. According to the list of business, the lower house will debate the Bill on Monday itself.
The Bharatiya Janata Party- (BJP)led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) is comfortably placed to ensure the Bill's passage in both the Houses. The Bill could come up for passage in the Rajya Sabha on Wednesday. The session ends on Friday.
The Bill seeks to amend the Citizenship Act to grant Indian citizenship to non-muslim refugees from Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan escaping religious persecution there.
Opposition parties, resigned to the fact that they lack the numbers to defeat or stall the Bill in the Houses, have decided upon different tactics that they would employ to highlight their reasons for opposing the Bill.
The primary argument of the Opposition would be that the Bill goes against the letter and spirit of the Constitution. “They (the government) are high on majority (numbers in Parliament), but very low on constitutional morality,” Trinamool Congress Rajya Sabha MP Derek O’brien said.
Congress Lok Sabha MP Shashi Tharoor has said the passage of Bill would mark the definitive victory of Mohammed Ali Jinnah’s thinking over that of Mahatma Gandhi’s. He said the exercise of granting citizenship on the basis of religion is a “cynical political exercise to single out and disenfranchise an entire community in India” and will reduce India to a “Hindutva version of Pakistan”.
Opposition members will point out that the Bill violates the tenets of equality and religious non-discrimination enshrined in Article 14 and 15 of the Constitution. The Trinamool Congress has given notices in both the Houses that the Bill should not be introduced.
The Communist Party of (India) Marxist has moved amendments that the references to specific countries and specific religions be replaced by a more encompassing clause stating that refugees “from (all) neighbouring countries” would come under its purview. Currently, the Bill mentions that members of all persecuted religions will be granted citizenship barring Islam.
Opposition members will also argue that the Bill will introduce multiple rules for citizenship, which is anti-constitutional; that it is anti-tribal; the National Register of Citizens (NRC) failed in Assam but the government is still insistent to roll it out in 27 states; that of the 1.9 million left out in the NRC in Assam included Hindus from West Bengal, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and other states; that members of Gurkha community have not found their names in the NRC; that NRC and
CAB are inextricably linked; the question of “deemed citizens” who have spent years in India; and that it is an attempt to divert attention from rising unemployment and economic slowdown.
Chief ministers of Opposition-run West Bengal, Chhattisgarh, and Punjab have said they oppose the Bill, and do not want an NRC in their states. Opposition parties did not want to reveal whether they would vote against the Bill or stage a walkout. The Congress had walked out when the Bill had come for discussion in the Lok Sabha in 2016. It had eventually lapsed as the government did not bring it to the Rajya Sabha. The Congress had also walked out on the Bill to repeal Article 370 in the Lok Sabha, but had voted against it in the Rajya Sabha. The Trinamool Congress had walked out in the two Houses on Article 370.
BJP General Secretary Ram Madhav said India was duty-bound to give citizenship to persecuted minorities from neighbouring countries as they were “victims” of the decision to divide the country on religious lines. He said a similar legislation 'Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam)' Act was enacted in 1950 by the then Congress government-led by Jawaharlal Nehru.
The Congress and its allies, like the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, the Nationalist Congress Party, Trinamool Congress, Left parties, Samajwadi Party, and Bahujan Samaj Party are opposing the Bill. According to sources, opposition parties have reached out to the Biju Janata Dal as well since they believe the Bill is “discriminatory” towards tribals. The Shiv Sena is likely to vote with the government, as would regional parties like the Telangana Rashtra Samiti, YSR Congress Party and others.