This time is different: Outside Opec+ nations, oil industry’s growth stalls

“This time is different” may be the most dangerous words in business: Billions of dollars have been lost betting that history won’t repeat itself. And yet now, in the oil world, it looks like this time really will be.

For the first time in decades, oil companies aren’t rushing to increase production to chase rising oil prices as Brent crude approaches $70. Even in the Permian, the prolific shale basin at the center of the US energy boom, drillers are resisting their traditional boomand-bust cycle of spending.

The oil industry is on the ropes, constrained by Wall Street investors demanding that companies spend less on drilling and instead return more money to shareholders, and climate change activists pushing against fossil fuels. Exxon Mobil is paradigmatic of the trend, after its humiliating defeat at the hands of a tiny activist elbowing itself onto the board.

The dramatic events in the industry last week only add to what is emerging as an opportunity for the producers of Opec+, giving the coalition led by Saudi Arabia and Russia more room for maneuver to bring back their own production. As non- OPEC output fails to rebound as fast as many expected — or feared based on past experience — the cartel is likely to continue adding more supply when it meets on June 1.

‘Criminalisation’

Shareholders are asking Exxon to drill less and focus on returning money to investors. “They have been throwing money down the drill hole like crazy,” Christopher Ailman, chief investment officer for CALSTRS. “We really saw that company just heading down the hole, not surviving into the future, unless they change and adapt. And now they have to.”

Exxon is unlikely to be alone. Royal Dutch Shell lost a landmark legal battle last week when a Dutch court told it to cut emissions significantly by 2030 — something that would require less oil production. Many in the industry fear a wave of lawsuits elsewhere, with western oil majors more immediate targets than the state-owned oil companies that make up much of Opec production.

“We see a shift from stigmatization toward criminalization of investing in higher oil production,” said Bob Mcnally, president of consultant Rapidan Energy Group and a former White House official.

While it’s true that non- Opec+ output is creeping back from the crash of 2020 — and the ultra-depressed levels of April and May last year — it’s far from a full recovery. Overall, non- Opec+ output will grow this year by 620,000 barrels a day, less than half the 1.3 million barrels a day it fell in 2020. The supply growth forecast through the rest of this year “comes nowhere close to matching” the expected increase in demand, according to the International Energy Agency.

Beyond 2021, oil output is likely to rise in a handful of nations, including the US, Brazil, Canada and new oilproducer Guyana. But production will decline elsewhere, from the UK to Colombia, Malaysia and Argentina.

As non- Opec+ production increases less than global oil demand, the cartel will be in control of the market, executives and traders said. It’s a major break with the past, when oil companies responded to higher prices by rushing to invest again, boosting non- Opec output and leaving the ministers led by Saudi Arabia’s Abdulaziz bin Salman with a much more difficult balancing act.

Drilling down

So far, the lack of non- Opec+ oil production growth isn’t registering much in the market. After all, the coronavirus pandemic continues to constrain global oil demand. It may be more noticeable later this year and into 2022. By then, vaccination campaigns against Covid-19 are likely to be bearing fruit, and the world will need more oil. The expected return of Iran into the market will provide some of that, but there will likely be a need for more.

When that happens, it will be largely up to Opec to plug the gap. One signal of how the recovery will be different this time is the US drilling count: It is gradually increasing, but the recovery is slower than it was after the last big oil price crash in 2008-09. Shale companies are sticking to their commitment to return more money to shareholders via dividends. While before the pandemic shale companies re-used 70-90 per cent of their cash flow into further drilling, they are now keeping that metric at around 50 per cent. The result is that US crude production has flat-lined at around 11 million barrels a day since July 2020. Outside the US and Canada, the outlook is even more somber: at the end of April, the ex-north America oil rig count stood at 523, lower than it was a year ago, and nearly 40 per cent below the same month two years earlier, according to data from Baker Hughes. When Saudi Energy Minister Prince Abdulaziz predicted earlier this year that “‘drill, baby, drill’ is gone for ever,” it sounded like a bold call. As ministers meet this week, they may dare to hope he’s right.