Fake news complicates fight against pandemic
India reported more than 300,000 new coronavirus infections for a 12th straight day on Monday, taking its overall number of cases to nearly 20 million. With 368,147 new cases over the past 24 hours, India’s total infections stand at 19.93 million, while total fatalities rose by 3,417 to 218,959, according to Health Ministry data. Experts say actual numbers across the country may be five to 10 times higher than the official tally. Authorities have been taken by surprise at the ferocity of the latest virus surge in the country and have encountered massive difficulties in ensuring enough stocks of resources like medical oxygen, essential drugs and hospital beds.
They are also struggling to come up with an effective strategy to curb the virus’ spread. Their task, however, is made more challenging by untrue news stories, conspiracy theories and unverified information circulating on social media platforms. The content in these messages and posts range from the origins of the second wave in India to the efficacy of vaccines and suggestions to boost immunity using home remedies.
“Of these, health-related misinformation is more prevalent and diverse, followed by religious misinformation,” Syed Nazakat, founder of Health Analytics Asia, a fact-checking initiative, told DW. “Most of the health misinformation deals with the pandemic and that too, when the country is also in the midst of a massive vaccination drive,” he said. Observers and activists say authorities haven’t taken enough action to stop the misinformation. In fact, some public figures and senior officials are themselves responsible for its spread.
In mid-April, when the number of COVID cases began to skyrocket, V K Paul, a senior government official who is at the forefront of the nation’s coronavirus response, recommended that people consult alternative therapy practitioners if they have mild or asymptomatic disease.
He also advised people to consume “chyawanprash” (a dietary supplement) and “kadha” (a brew of herbs and spices) to improve their immunity. His statement triggered criticism from doctors who said such recommendations could encourage people to try untested therapies and wait too long to seek medical help. “This is astounding and so misleading. It will encourage people to sit at home, drinking such concoctions and by the time they reach hospital, it will be too late,” Rajan Sharma, ex-national president of the Indian Medical Association, told DW.
Apar Gupta, executive director of the Internet Freedom Foundation, shared a similar view.
“When you have public authorities endorsing such appeals, there is obviously a lack of respect for science. What effect do you think it will have on those consuming social media?” Gupta told DW. Experts believe that people’s low trust in news media and a weak public service media, coupled with a fragmented audience and high social media use, have been responsible for the rapid and wide spread of misinformation.
Consumption of social media content has increased enormously since the Indian government imposed a strict nationwide lockdown in March last year to control the spread of the virus. WhatsApp, which has over 500 million users in the country, is the platform through which most misinformation is being peddled. “The increasing reach of social media further intensifies the misinformation crisis,” Gupta said. “Many of these videos and memes are recycled as they don’t evaporate easily from cyberspace. Even after this avalanche of misinformation is debunked, there are still people who are unsure of what to believe,” Prateek Waghre, a research analyst at the Takshashila Institution, told DW.