Imran’s New Pakistan is full of the same old faces
The new PM cannot hope to transform Pakistan into a social welfare state if it is a national security state
Imran Khan’s dream has finally been fulfilled 22 years in to his political career: a career that started with idealism and came to be marked by pragmatism. His real political career has just begun.
We all knew the outcome of these elections but what did surprise a lot of us was the way it was pulled off a few hours after polling ended on July 25. The results of the elections in Pakistan were pre-determined. But what happened before the final results were announced left many of us shocked at how the powers-that-be did not even want to hide how much they were influencing the results. Even in a country where manipulating elections is nothing new, this brazenness was something new altogether.
I have been in the media for more than a decade now and have seen/covered the previous two elections, but have never witnessed the kind of censorship that we faced this time around. We had to talk in a roundabout way to say that these elections were rigged. When one said something to this effect, even in private settings, some would tell us there is nothing one can do about it, so let’s move forward. How does one move forward? How does one deal with a ‘Naya Paki- stan’ full of puraanay chehray (old faces) who are adamant that they will bring ‘tabdeeli’ (change)? Apart from a couple of people, most of Khan’s cabinet has served under other governments.
Khan’s victory speech after the elections hit all the right notes. He talked about good relations with India and Afghanistan. Like his predecessors, Khan wants good relations with India and other neighbouring countries. Like his predecessors, he will soon find out that he will not be calling the final shots vis-à-vis Indo-Pak relations.
On the day of the elections of the PM in the National Assembly, Khan and his party were heckled by the PML-N members. Khan delivered a speech that sounded more like his Opposition-day speeches. What happened to the Khan who had apparently matured and did not believe in political victimisation? He was never there, to begin with.
Maybe to counter all this criticism, Prime Minister Khan promised the sky. Let’s hope he is able to deliver.
Let me repeat something a friend said about his speech: you cannot make Pakistan a social welfare state if yours is a national security state. Khan talked about austerity but did not mention the defence budget or the lavish lifestyles being enjoyed by top military officials and judiciary. These two institutions are the sacred cows of Pakistan. The less said about them, the better chance of survival for a politician and/or anyone.